You Can Get Fired During FMLA Leave

Bob Gregg, partner in Boardman Law Firm, shares his roundup of diversity-related legal issues. He can be reached at rgregg@boardmanlawfirm.com.


The federal Family & Medical Leave Act (FMLA) grants eligible full-time employees (those who have worked at least 1,250 hours during a 12-month period) at organizations with a workforce of 50 or more up to 12 weeks of unpaid leave for the birth and care of a newborn; the adoption of a child or foster child; the care of an immediate family member with a serious health condition; and personal medical leave because of a serious health condition. Here are several recent FMLA legal decisions.

Layoff based on suspect performance evaluation violates FMLA. The law does not forbid layoff of an employee who is on FMLA leave if the action would have occurred anyway had he or she not been on leave. In Cutcher v. Kmart Corp. (6th Cir., 2010), an employee on FMLA was part of a workforce reduction. The company based layoffs on performance evaluations, and the plaintiff’s evaluation was low. However, the court found evidence to suspect the poor evaluation: It was done during the employee’s FMLA absence. She had received an “exceeds expectations” evaluation just four weeks earlier, immediately before taking FMLA leave. Obviously, her work performance could not deteriorate while she was not present at work, so the layoff evaluation seemed to be a pretext to eliminate a person who had exercised FMLA rights.

FMLA eligibility can start in the middle of unqualified leave. An employee with less than a year’s service was granted short-term medical leave for surgery. Medical complications resulted and the employee was unable to return to work when the short-term leave expired. The company then terminated the individual. But the employee passed the one-year mark during the original approved leave. In Porcillo v. Vistar Corp. (M.D. Fla., 2010), the court ruled that FMLA eligibility started at that pointand the employer should have given up to 12 more weeks of extended FMLA before discharge.

Walt Disney World is not the proper place for FMLA. Just days after being counseled for poor performance, a sheriff’s department investigator was diagnosed with cytomegalovirus and then stayed off work for several weeks. She spent two of those weeks entertaining a house guest and visiting Florida tourist attractions. Although the employee submitted several doctors’ notes during the leave, none verified that the condition was serious enough to render her unable to perform duties. She was subsequently terminated. In Gunzburger v. Sheriff of Broward County (11th Cir., 2010), the court found in favor of the defendant. The plaintiff’s activities were inconsistent with a need for FMLA leave, and she did not provide adequate medical proof of a serious condition.

For more on work/life issues, listen to our work/life webinar at www.BestPractices.DiversityInc.com.

Latest News

Oak Park, Illinois

Illinois Professor Suspended, Charged with Hate Crime After Allegedly Spitting on Black Woman and Using Racial Slur

An Illinois professor has been suspended from his job and charged with a hate crime after he allegedly spat on and racially attacked a Black female driver in a suburban Chicago grocery store parking lot earlier this month. Antonio Planas of NBC News has reported that Alberto Friedmann, a professor…

Joaquin Castro

New Research Shows a Continued Lack of Hispanic and Latinx Representation in Movies, Media and Publishing

In a bit of disheartening news in the midst of Hispanic Heritage Month, a new government study has confirmed that Latinx individuals are vastly under-included and underrepresented in many parts of the media world. Astrid Galvan of the Associated Press reported on the study from the U.S. Government Accountability Office,…

Newberg, Oregon

Oregon School Employee Suspended for Showing Up to Work in Blackface To Protest State Vaccination Policies

Racial controversies continue to mount at the Newberg Public School system located in the suburbs of Portland, Oregon. Last week, students in the district’s high school conducted a mock “slave auction” on social media in which they ridiculed fellow classmates and discussed how much they would or wouldn’t pay to…

Marriott International Reports on Its Environmental, Social and Governance (ESG) Progress

Originally published at news.marriott.com. Marriott International is a DiversityInc Hall of Fame company.   On Sept. 14, Marriott International, Inc. released its 2021 Serve 360 Report presenting data from 2020 and demonstrating its Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) efforts toward the company’s 2025 Sustainability and Social Impact Goals. The Report…