Upper Crust Bakery, DOJ, immigration
Delicious Bread Bakery Sweets Food Starbucks

Upper Crust Bakery Reaches Settlement with DOJ Over Immigration Employment Discrimination

The Department of Justice (DOJ) has reached a settlement agreement with Arizona-based company Upper Crust Bakery over a suit involving immigration status discrimination.

Upper Crust Bakery, which provides baked goods for companies like Starbucks, Cotsco and Kroger’s discriminated against certain employees by requiring them to provide specific immigration documents to prove they were authorized to work. These documents were unnecessary and specific. Therefore the action was in violation of the Immigration and Nationality Act (INA), which contains most provisions of immigration law in the U.S. and prevents unfair immigration-related employment practices and other forms of discrimination.

The Form I-9 prospective employees are required to fill out upon their hiring requires employees to either provide one identification document from the “A” list, or one from the “B” list and one from the “C” list. Items on the “A” list include a U.S. Passport or Permanent Resident Card, among others. The “B” list provides 10 approved items, including a U.S. state driver’s license and Native American tribal document. The “C” list includes items such as a Social Security card and employment authorization document issued by the Department of Homeland Security.

The I-9 document specifically notes an employer may not dictate which documents an employee chooses to submit.

The DOJ determined the bakery was in violation of the INA, engaging in a pattern of unfair documentary practices against employees on the grounds of their citizenship. The document says the bakery required noncitizen employees to provide a Department of Homeland Security-issued employment eligibility document (a “C”-list item) and rejected other documents listed as acceptable on the I-9 list. They also allowed citizens to provide only identification documents and Social Security cards (“B”-list items) without requiring other documents necessary to prove employment verification.

Related Story: Trump’s ‘Go Back’ Tweets Against Congresswomen of Color Would Be Considered Workplace Discrimination

Under the DOJ settlement, Upper Crust Bakery will pay $45,000, provide training for its human resources department on the requirements of the INA’s anti-discrimination provision and be subject to compliance monitoring by the DOJ for the next two years.

Recently Koch Foods, one of the largest poultry suppliers in the world settled a class employment discrimination lawsuit for $3,750 million for sexual harassment, national origin and race discrimination as well as retaliation. The plant was also one of the subjects of the largest single-state worksite immigration raid in the country.

Foreign-born people make up a significant chunk of the U.S. labor force. In 2018, there were 28.2 million documented foreign-born people in the labor force, 17.4% of the total, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics.

Latest News

Southern Company Renders Aid in Isaias’ Wake

Originally published on southerncompany.com. Nearly a thousand Southern Company system resources responded to help restore power in the Northeast after Tropical Storm Isaias battered the region, leaving more than 3.5 million customers without power from South Carolina to New England. As members of the Southeastern Electric Exchange, Southern Company has…

Cigna

Cigna Names Noelle Eder, Global Chief Information Officer

Originally published on cigna.com.  BLOOMFIELD, Conn., Aug. 12, 2020 — Cigna has named Noelle Eder, Global Chief Information Officer, effective September 14. She will report to David M. Cordani, President and Chief Executive Officer and will serve as a member of the Enterprise Leadership Team. Eder will lead Cigna’s global technology strategy, and oversee…

Marriott International

Marriott International Introduces New Content On Digital Platform For Meetings & Events

Following the announcement of Marriott International’s Commitment to Clean and Global Cleanliness Council, Marriott has introduced digital content about redefined processes and reimagined spaces guided by cleanliness experts and best practices to help hosts, organizers and attendees plan and execute meetings and connect with confidence. Recognized as an industry leader…