The Oscar ‘Diversity’ Plan is Bogus

The recent splashy announcement that the Academy of Motion Picture Arts was going to “double” their “diversity” in the aftermath of the uproar over yet another all-white Oscars is bogus. Here’s how you can tell:

1. Use of words that provide no contrast, lack of a plan to accomplish the goal and a lack of transparency are usually signs of fraud in business. “Double” Double what, exactly The goal was released without releasing the demographics of the people who vote for the Oscars. The most recent research was done by the Los Angeles Times, and the article shows that the Academy is overwhelmingly white (93 percent), older (90 percent over 40) and male (77 percent). If you take them at their word, the Academy’s goal is 84 percent white and 54 percent women — in other words, the Academy’s press release should be headlined: Hollywood aspires to achieve the racial diversity of 1960!

Given the lack of opportunity for anyone other than white people in Hollywood throughout its history, I have no idea how they’re going to even get their diversity to reach 1960 levels. No plan was presented, so I wonder if they have any idea.

2. The person making the announcement is conspicuously unlike the people who are actually responsible. The president of the Academy is Cheryl Boone Isaacs, a career publicist and a Black woman. She was elected to the position in 2013 by the Academy board of governors; she was the third woman (and first Black) in the Academy’s history be elected to the position. She is unlike 97 percent of the Academy — a number that defines “token” — and she gets to be the public face for the bad behavior of people who don’t look like her. Dr. Carson, are you paying attention

3. Misuse of the word diversity. All people are part of diversity. Using “diversity” as a euphemism for non-white men allows the white men to think of themselves as normal and everyone else as abnormal or “diverse.” In the case of the Oscars, the response from Hollywood is clearly on a Black/white axis. Sales numbers tell me that this is far more complicated, and dire, than they are reacting to:

– 62 percent of tickets sold are to people under age 40, half to women.

– 46 percent of tickets sold (in the U.S.) are to non-white people. Hispanics and Asians over-index the rest of the population as frequent moviegoers.

Box office sales of U.S. films are now larger in Asia that they are in the United States.

– Box office gross receipts and attendance are declining in the United States. People under 40 account for most tickets sold; however, attendance among younger people declined more sharply.

– Tickets sold per person have declined, and the price of tickets has risen less than the rate of inflation.

The real reason the Academy should change is business. The overwhelming majority of box office dollars are not coming from the demographic almost completely represented by the Academy. Therefore, the awards go to people who are not represented by the audience, and the almost all white leadership of the movie industry chases the rabbit down the rabbit hole, as they covet the Award that takes them down the path to irrelevancy.

A “diversity” initiative should have solid business reasons behind it, clear goals with starting and ending points and the metrics and transparency necessary to understand the process. The effort should be announced by people who have the authority to be accountable for change.

Hollywood is leaking dollars; stagnant and declining US box office sales are masked by rising global box office sales. The consumer is not reflected in Hollywood studios, and this is having its consequences in the end product, which is not as attractive as it once was to the consumer — opening the door for competitors around the world. It’s a slow fade now, but that usually has its consequences. Ask the record industry. Or the taxi industry. Or the newspaper industry. Or the American car industry.

Latest News

Toyota Earns the Most R&D Patents Among Automakers in IPO Rankings for 8th Consecutive Year

Originally published at Toyota ranked No. 7 on The DiversityInc Top 50 Companies for Diversity list in 2021.   The United States Patent and Trademark Office awarded Toyota more patents than any other automaker in 2021, according to an annual ranking by the Intellectual Property Owners Association (IPO). Toyota’s engineers…

Wells Fargo Announces New Initiative To Help Customers Avoid Overdraft Fees and Meet Short-Term Cash Needs

Originally published at Wells Fargo ranked No. 25 on The DiversityInc Top 50 Companies for Diversity list in 2021.   Wells Fargo announced new efforts to limit overdraft-related fees and give customers more flexible options to meet their personal financial needs. These offerings, which include earlier access to direct deposits,…

multi race business woman

New Report Shows Significant Increase in Female and Black Representation in the Executive Boardroom

Diversity and inclusion appear to be successfully increasing among America’s largest and most successful companies. The finding comes from a new report conducted by executive recruiting firm Crist Kolder Associates as part of its review of DEI representation in executive offices. Ariel Zilber of the New York Post reported that…

Taco Bell

Taco Bell Creates Business School To Help Underrepresented Groups Become Franchise Owners

Taco Bell and the popular fast-food chain’s owner Yum! Brands have entered the DEI arena with a new business school designed to help people of all backgrounds — and people of color in particular — advance into restaurant ownership. Jonathan Maze of Restaurant Business reported that “a select group of…

LGBTQ dog tags

US Government Will Now Allow Veterans To Identify As Trans on Veteran Affairs Medical Records

In another giant leap forward for LGBTQ+ rights and equality in the military, the federal government has announced that military veterans can now officially identify as trans in their official medical records. Brody Levesque of the Los Angeles Blade reported that Veterans Affairs Secretary Denis McDonough has confirmed that veterans…