Tamir Rice's Age, Size Repeatedly Made an Issue in Shooting Investigation

By Michael Nam


Prior to the release of the official investigation into the shooting death of 12-year-old Tamir Rice by police officers Timothy Loehmann and Frank Garmback, newsnet5 out of Cleveland reported sources that stated the Cuyahoga County Sheriff’s Office found no evidence of a crime, but sections of the report show some troubling details, especially in the need to cast the young victim as a physically menacing and seemingly less innocent individual.

In a redacted interview, Detective David Jacobs inquires into the story of a woman who mentioned seeing pictures of Tamir Rice on social media in a chance encounter with Cleveland Police first district Sergeant Janell Rutherford.

Apparently, investigators spent quite a bit of time trying to track down images that showed Tamir Rice looking older than the photos seen by the public, as well as looking for images of him with a gun, which is unsurprising considering the time and effort that Cleveland Police have spent framing Rice as looking threatening enough for an officer to feel justified in shooting him.

Another interview, this time with an FBI agent who was on the scene attempting to administer aid to the dying boy, also emphasized Tamir’s appearance:

Three months following the shooting, detectives conducted a follow-up interview with the 911 caller who had reported the gun was “probably a fake” and that Rice was likely a juvenile during the call. However, while interviewed by police, he describes Rice as looking to be around 20-years-old, a change the detectives noted, but the witness doesn’t actually explain the difference in his story.

The attempt to cast the victim, Rice, into the mold of someone far more threatening in order to justify his homicide fits in with research that shows law enforcement officers often view Black children and adolescents as far older and less innocent, according to the American Psychological Association.

“Children in most societies are considered to be in a distinct group with characteristics such as innocence and the need for protection,” said Phillip Atiba Goff, PhD, of the University of California, Los Angeles. “Our research found that black boys can be seen as responsible for their actions at an age when white boys still benefit from the assumption that children are essentially innocent.”

Perception of Tamir Rice as being an older, threatening suspect could lead to what appears to be the overreacting behavior of the police officers who shot the boy.

ThinkProgress extracted four key moments recorded in the official investigation about the officer’s reactions:

Loehmann told officers at the scene that he had repeatedly warned Rice to show his hands prior to shooting him.

None of the witnesses heard the officers give Rice verbal commands before the shooting.

Loehmann shot Rice within 2 seconds after exiting his vehicle.

Both officers refused to cooperate with the investigation.

It’s hard to tell at what age a Black male is old and threatening enough to be given just two seconds to comply with an alleged police order before the officers feel required to open fire.

Despite newsnet5’s reporting, the official position of the Cuyahoga County Sheriff’s Department is that they draw no conclusions based on their investigation, and that it’s entirely up to the prosecutor and the grand jury to file charges. However, some of the avenues of investigation they present are troubling in the way the shooting victim’s appearance and background are made such an issue.

Latest News

Johnson & Johnson Names Dr. Nadja West, Retired United States Army Lieutenant General and Former United States Army Surgeon General to its Board of Directors

Originally published on jnj.com. Johnson & Johnson is a DiversityInc Hall of Fame company. Johnson & Johnson announced today that Dr. Nadja West, retired United States Army lieutenant general and former United States Army Surgeon General has been appointed to its Board of Directors. “I am pleased to welcome Dr….

AT&T

AT&T Celebrates the Aspire Accelerator Class of 2020

Originally published on ATT.com. AT&T is a DiversityInc Hall of Fame company. Immersed Games and Social Cipher win annual “Pitches with Purpose” competition; each receive $25K award Yesterday, eight education technology companies graduated from the Aspire Accelerator and competed in an all-virtual “Shark Tank”-style “Pitches with Purpose” for two $25,000 prizes…

NelsonHall Recognizes ADP as a Leader in the Efficiency Focused NEAT Graph for Cloud-Based HR Transformation Services 2020 Evaluation

Originally published on ADP.com. ADP ranked No. 4 on The DiversityInc Top 50 Companies for Diversity list in 2020. ADP acknowledged for improving processes, lowering costs and providing better decision-making driven by analytics and automation for clients Industry analyst firm NelsonHall has positioned ADP as a Leader in its Efficiency Focused…

Humana

Humana CEO Bruce Broussard Named Businessperson of the Year

Originally posted on Humana LinkedIn. Humana ranked No. 25 for The DiversityInc Top 50 Companies for Diversity list in 2020. We’d like to congratulate CEO Bruce Broussard on being named one of Fortune‘s 2020 Businesspersons of the Year. “Since being named CEO of the health insurer in 2013, Broussard has continued Humana’s push into…

Child studying to improve test scores

Test Scores Drop Dramatically for Black, Hispanic and Poor Children Due to COVID-19; Nasdaq Moves to Require Diversity for Listed Companies; and More

Math and reading test scores have dropped dramatically for Black, Hispanic and poor children due to COVID-19, new study warns. Results of lockdowns, home-schooling, and Zoom classrooms as a result of COVID-19 are starting to come in, and the numbers aren’t good. According to a review of more than 4…

Trump

The Platinum Plan: How Trump Increased His Black Vote by 50% and What We Can Learn From It

Do you know what Donald Trump’s “Platinum Plan” was? Most Black people I know do. Most white people have never heard of it. The plan — a two-page document released just weeks before the 2020 election — details the four pillars of Trump’s commitment to Black Americans (Opportunity, Security, Prosperity…

Hershey Statement on Cocoa Sustainability and Supporting the Living Income Differential

Originally published on thehersheycompany.com. Hershey’s commitment to improving cocoa farmer livelihoods and ensuring a long-term sustainable cocoa supply is unwavering. Solving the many challenges within cocoa production, such as low incomes, poverty, child labor and environmental protection will be possible only through collaboration and cooperation across industry, governments, and civil…