Supreme Court Rules: Abercrombie & Fitch Discriminated Against Muslim Applicant Who Wore Headscarf

Abercrombie & Fitch has once again lost a diversity and inclusion battle this time the U.S. Supreme Court ruled the company was wrong to turn down a Muslim job applicant because she wore a headscarf. The company had said the scarf didn’t fit its dress code, which required a “classic East Coast collegiate style.”


The Supreme Court’s decision means that failing to accommodate religious practices and observations is discrimination, unless the accommodation provides a major hardship for employers.

This is the second time this term the court has handled a religious accommodation involving a Muslim planitiff. The other case, in January, was Holt vs. Hobbs, in which the court unanimously found that Arkansas federal officials discriminated when they refused to allow a Muslin prisoner to grow a beard. Hobby Lobby v. Burwell, a controversial religious-freedom case decided at the end of the last term, ruled that companies could refuse to cover contraception on insurance plans because of owners’ beliefs.

Tbe bigger legal question is whether corporations can actually have religious beliefs but that isn’t a major issue in the Abercrombie case. Legal officials say this case is pure discrimination Samantha was qualified to work at the company but the managers believed her headscarf violated their “preferred appearance” policies. The appeals court had said she should have told Abercrombie she needed a religious accommodation to work there but the Supreme Court disagreed. The burden, they said, is on the company, not the job applicant.

In the Abercrombie case, Justice Antonin Scalia said the company’s decision not to hire the applicant, Samantha Elauf, was motivated by not wanting to accommodate her religious practice. Justice Scalia was supported by all other justices except Justice Clarence Thomas in finding this a case of federal religious discrimination.

In his written opinion, Justice Scalia stated: “An employer may not make an applicant’s religious practice, confirmed or otherwise, a factor in employment decisions.”

The case dates back to 2008, when Samantha first applied for the position. She told The New York Times her experience made her feel “disrespected because of my religious beliefs,” she said. “I was born in the United States, and I thought I was the same as everyone else.”

An Abercrombie spokesperson stated that the company’s dress code has changed since then, allowing workers to be “more individualistic.”

This is not the first time Abercrombie has been in the news for discriminatory actions.

Two years ago, the company came under fire for its decision not to sell women’s clothes in any size larger than a 10. CEO Mike Jeffries lost his job after he was sued for age discrimination when a former pilot sued and details came out that he liked younger flight attendants and required them to wear certain types of underwear.

Latest News

Three BASF Women Leaders Honored at the Manufacturing Institute’s 2021 STEP Ahead Awards

Originally published at basf.com. BASF ranked No. 12 on The DiversityInc Top 50 Companies for Diversity list in 2021.   Three BASF leaders in manufacturing were among 130 women recognized nationally at The Manufacturing Institute’s ninth annual STEP Ahead Awards. Focusing on science, technology, engineering and production (STEP), the program recognizes women…

Wells Fargo Pledges $1 Million to the Thurgood Marshall College Fund for HBCU Seniors

Originally published at newsroom.wf.com. Wells Fargo ranked No. 25 on The DiversityInc Top 50 Companies for Diversity list in 2021.   Wells Fargo and the Thurgood Marshall College Fund (TMCF) are teaming up to help close the graduation gap for college seniors attending Historically Black Colleges and Universities (HBCUs). The $1 million Thurgood Marshall…

Hershey Employees and Retirees in the US and Canada Pledged More Than $900,000 in 2021 To Support Nonprofit Organizations

Originally published on LinkedIn. The Hershey Company ranked No. 10 on The DiversityInc Top 50 Companies for Diversity list in 2021.    Each year, our Season of Giving campaign encourages Hershey employees to make a difference by supporting nonprofit organizations which they find to be meaningful. Employees and retirees in…

Creating Windows and Mirrors: Hershey’s Amber Murayi on Diversity, Equity and Inclusion at the ‘World’s Top Female-Friendly Company’

Amber Murayi is the Hershey Company’s Senior Director of Enterprise Strategy & Business Model Innovation & Co-lead of the Women’s Business Resource Group. The Hershey Company ranked No. 10 on The DiversityInc Top 50 Companies for Diversity list in 2021.    My position affords me a unique view of DEI…

Author Alice Sebold

Author Alice Sebold Apologizes for Her Role in the Wrongful Conviction of the Black Man Charged With Raping Her

In her acclaimed 1999 memoir Lucky, author Alice Sebold told the story of being raped in 1981 when she was a student at Syracuse University. The case resulted in a Black man named Anthony Broadwater being convicted and sent to prison. Sadly, Broadwater was innocent and wrongfully convicted — and…

Black renters

New Study Reveals Landlords Consistently Discriminate Against Potential Renters With Black or Hispanic ‘Sounding’ Names

In the largest study of its kind ever conducted, researchers with the National Bureau of Economic Research have uncovered what many people of color already know when hunting for an apartment or home: most landlords consistently discriminate or harbor bias against non-white individuals looking to rent their property.  Bloomberg’s Kelsey…