Supreme Court Decides To Revisit Affirmative Action

By Sheryl Estrada

The Supreme Court is once again involved in the affirmative action case Abigail Fisher vs. The University of Austin at Texas, announcing Monday it will hear an appeal by Fisher, for a second time, this fall.


Fisher filed a lawsuit in 2008 after she was denied admission to the University of Texas at Austin. As a white applicant, she claimed she experiencedreverse discrimination, and use of race as a consideration in admission decisions isin violation of the equal protection clause of the Fourteenth Amendment.

In Texas, the top 10 percent rule provides all graduating high school students who finish in thetop 10 percentof class guaranteed admission at any public university in the state. The rule was said to create racial diversity. In 2009, the rule changed to assure admission to the University of Texas at Austin for the top eight percent of high school seniors instead of the top 10 percent. The school also considers race and other factors in admission.

Fisher did not meet the requirements to be considered in the top 10 percent when she applied for admissionin 2008. Her argument is other students accepted to the school that were not top 10 applicants and had lower test scores than hers were entitled to racial preferences.

The Western District of Texas upheld the legality of the university’s admission policy in a summary judgment in 2009. Fisher’s case was appealed to the Fifth Circuit in 2011, which also ruled in the school’s favor.

Her case reached the Supreme Court for the first time in October 2012, after she graduated from an out-of-state school. The justices heard the case but did not act for eight months. In June 2013, in a 7-1 ruling, the Supreme Court gave Fisher another chance in the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit in New Orleans. It is considered one of the most conservative courts in the country.

In July 2014, a three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit upheld, 2 to 1, that the University of Texas at Austin can continue using affirmative action in its admission policies. In February, Fisher appealed to the Supreme Court for a second time prompting a review this fall.

Fisher’s appeals to the court have been facilitated by The Project on Fair Representation (POFR) directed by Eric Blum. Blum controls thelegal-defense fund, which has the sole purpose to “facilitate pro bono legal representation to political subdivisions and individuals that wish to challenge government distinctions and preferences made on the basis of race and ethnicity.” Essentially, the nonprofit funds lawsuits that have the possibility to eliminate partialities based on race.

According to an investigative report by ProPublica in 2013, the University at Texas, Austin did offer provisional admission to students with lower grades and test scores than Fisher the year she applied; however, “Five of those students were Black or Latino. Forty-two were white.”

Fisher’s grade point average and SAT scores simply may not have been competitive enough for the flagship university:

Neither Fisher nor Blum mentioned those 42 applicants in interviews. Nor did they acknowledge the 168 Black and Latino students with grades as good as or better than Fisher’s who were also denied entry into the university that year. Also left unsaid is the fact that Fisher turned down a standard UT offer under which she could have gone to the university her sophomore year if she earned a 3.2 GPA at another Texas university school in her freshman year.

In court filings, university officials claim that “even if Fisher received points for her race and every other personal achievement factor, the letter she received in the mail still would have said no.”

Justices such as Antonin Scalia and Clarence Thomas have been adamant about their rejection of affirmative action.

In 2013, in his separate opinion on Fisher v. University of Texas at Austin, Thomas, the only Black judge on the court, rejected that diversity in education has educational benefits.

“As should be obvious, there is nothing ‘pressing’ or ‘necessary’ about obtaining whatever educational benefits may flow from racial diversity,” he wrote.

In April 2014, the Supreme Court upheld a constitutional amendment that bans affirmative action in admissions to Michigan’s public universities.

According to the New York Times, “In states that have banned affirmative action in college admissions, prominent public universities have tended to enroll fewer Black and Hispanic freshmen.”

Latest News

Three BASF Women Leaders Honored at the Manufacturing Institute’s 2021 STEP Ahead Awards

Originally published at basf.com. BASF ranked No. 12 on The DiversityInc Top 50 Companies for Diversity list in 2021.   Three BASF leaders in manufacturing were among 130 women recognized nationally at The Manufacturing Institute’s ninth annual STEP Ahead Awards. Focusing on science, technology, engineering and production (STEP), the program recognizes women…

Wells Fargo Pledges $1 Million to the Thurgood Marshall College Fund for HBCU Seniors

Originally published at newsroom.wf.com. Wells Fargo ranked No. 25 on The DiversityInc Top 50 Companies for Diversity list in 2021.   Wells Fargo and the Thurgood Marshall College Fund (TMCF) are teaming up to help close the graduation gap for college seniors attending Historically Black Colleges and Universities (HBCUs). The $1 million Thurgood Marshall…

Hershey Employees and Retirees in the US and Canada Pledged More Than $900,000 in 2021 To Support Nonprofit Organizations

Originally published on LinkedIn. The Hershey Company ranked No. 10 on The DiversityInc Top 50 Companies for Diversity list in 2021.    Each year, our Season of Giving campaign encourages Hershey employees to make a difference by supporting nonprofit organizations which they find to be meaningful. Employees and retirees in…

Creating Windows and Mirrors: Hershey’s Amber Murayi on Diversity, Equity and Inclusion at the ‘World’s Top Female-Friendly Company’

Amber Murayi is the Hershey Company’s Senior Director of Enterprise Strategy & Business Model Innovation & Co-lead of the Women’s Business Resource Group. The Hershey Company ranked No. 10 on The DiversityInc Top 50 Companies for Diversity list in 2021.    My position affords me a unique view of DEI…

Author Alice Sebold

Author Alice Sebold Apologizes for Her Role in the Wrongful Conviction of the Black Man Charged With Raping Her

In her acclaimed 1999 memoir Lucky, author Alice Sebold told the story of being raped in 1981 when she was a student at Syracuse University. The case resulted in a Black man named Anthony Broadwater being convicted and sent to prison. Sadly, Broadwater was innocent and wrongfully convicted — and…

Black renters

New Study Reveals Landlords Consistently Discriminate Against Potential Renters With Black or Hispanic ‘Sounding’ Names

In the largest study of its kind ever conducted, researchers with the National Bureau of Economic Research have uncovered what many people of color already know when hunting for an apartment or home: most landlords consistently discriminate or harbor bias against non-white individuals looking to rent their property.  Bloomberg’s Kelsey…