supreme court
The United States Supreme Court Building. Photo credit: By David Dugan, CC BY-SA 3.0, Link

Supreme Court Blocks Trump Administration From Adding Citizenship Question to 2020 Census

The Supreme Court ruled on Thursday that the Trump administration cannot add a citizenship question to the 2020 census and sent the case back to lower court. The Justices determined the Department of Commerce did not provide a sufficient explanation of why the question should be added.

Commerce Secretary Wilbur Ross sought to incorporate the citizenship question into the census, even though there was evidence that it wasn’t a good idea.

Related Story: Census Citizenship Question Creates Advantage for ‘Republicans and Non-Hispanic Whites’: Report

States, including New York, sued the Trump administration, arguing that adding the question would jeopardize the essential information the U.S. government collects. Manhattan-based U.S. District Judge Jesse Furman ruled on Jan. 15 that Ross’ decision to add the question violated a federal law called the Administrative Procedure Act.

The Court made its ruling in the case — Department of Commerce v. New York. The opinion, written by Chief Justice John Roberts, partially upheld Furman’s decision against the census question. The Court’s decision is surprising because of its conservative majority. The expectation was that the Justices would agree with the Trump administration. 

“We are pleased with the Supreme Court’s decision today,” New York Attorney General Letitia James said in a statement. “This one question could have caused a substantial undercount, particularly of noncitizens and Latinos.

“Thanks to the Court, the census will remain a tool for delivering on our government’s promise of fairness and equity, and states, like New York, will not be shortchanged out of critical resources or political representation.”

James also cautioned that “many threats continue to lie ahead from the Trump Administration and we will not stop fighting.”

During a hearing in March, before the House Oversight Committee, Wilbur Ross was under fire by Democrats.

Rep. Ocasio-Cortez (D-N.Y.), who questioned Ross in the seventh hour of the hearing, made clear that he failed to consult with the U.S. Census Bureau experts. Ross received guidance from Kris Kobach.

Ocasio-Cortez referred to a July 2017 email from Kobach, then-Kansas secretary of state who was well-known for voter suppression, to Ross.

“It’s all there in black and white,” she said.

The email showed that Kobach was in favor of adding the citizenship question.

Ocasio-Cortez also said that Ross violated the U.S. Census Act by not submitting a report on the suggested change to Congress.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Latest News

ENGIE Chooses Accenture, Salesforce and Vlocity to Support its Customer Relations and Help Them Achieve Their Zero-Carbon Transition

Originally posted on With a global, unified industry-specific CRM, ENGIE is able to get a 360-degree customer view and help even more companies transition to zero-carbon energy SAN FRANCISCO, DREAMFORCE; Nov. 19, 2019 – Accenture (NYSE: ACN), Salesforce (NYSE: CRM) and Vlocity Inc. today announced the companies are teaming up with…

TIAA Holds SoPro Business Resource Group Summit

TIAA recently launched its 10th Business Resource Group (BRG): SoPro, for Seasoned Professionals of TIAA. The SoPro BRG’s mission is to maximize the impact of TIAA’s network of seasoned professionals by bridging generational differences and promoting cross-cultural collaboration by sharing knowledge and experiences. This includes future collaboration and partnership with…

Boeing Programs Receive Aviation Week Laureate Awards

Originally published on ecoDemonstrator and Ground-based Midcourse Defense programs recognized for achievements in aerospace wo Boeing [NYSE:BA] programs were honored today with Aviation Week Laureate Awards for extraordinary achievements in aerospace. Boeing’s ecoDemonstrator program was recognized in the Commercial Aviation Sustainability category. The ecoDemonstrator takes promising technologies out of the…

nonprofit, hr, diversity

Study Finds Many Nonprofits Conscious of Staff Diversity, But Still Struggling with Implementation

Nonprofit HR released its 2019 diversity report Tuesday, which included the results from surveys of 566 nonprofit organizations throughout North America. These organizations were surveyed on their diversity practices, and the results revealed that though many organizations have diversity statements and leaders who tout diversity, the sentiments aren’t always backed…

Fraternity Activities Suspended at Syracuse University Following Latest Racist Incident, Investigation into Racist Graffiti Ongoing

Syracuse University has a new development in its latest string of racist incidents. On Sunday morning, the university suspended all social activities at fraternities after a group of students, including members of the fraternity Alpha Chi Rho, called a Black female student a racial slur on Saturday night. The altercation…

management coworker joke Breakfast Club Rakevion White ASU Arizona restaurant Instagram

Phoenix Restaurant Employees Racially Target Black Server, Management Slow to Fire Racist Co-worker

Rakevion White, a 21-year-old Black Arizona State University (ASU) student, was subjected to racial targeting at his job as a server at the Breakfast Club in Phoenix, according to a BuzzFeed News article published Tuesday. After initially saying it wouldn’t terminate the employee responsible for targeting White, the Breakfast Club…