Study: Seeing Successful Black People Makes Non-Blacks Deny Racism

By Albert Lin

Simmons, Morrison, Frazier

According to a recent study in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, incidental exposure to a Black person who is successful in a nonstereotypical setting (for example, former Brown University President Ruth Simmons or Nobel Prizewinning author Toni Morrison) is enough to make people more likely to believe that systemic racism does not exist.

“People shifted the blame from vestiges of racism in America to problems in Black communities,” co-author Clayton Critcher told The Huffington Post.

Authors Critcher, of the University of California, Berkeley, and Jane Risen, of the University of Chicago, presented several hundred participants with a series of photos of somewhat famous people. In most cases, all the images were of white men and women. However, a control group was shown pictures that included equivalent Black peoplefor example, Merck & Co. Chairman, President and CEO Kenneth Frazier in place of Lockheed Martin Executive Chairman Robert Stevens.

Subjects were then asked their opinion on the role of race in America, and whether they felt race influences workplace success. Researchers found that whites, Latinos and Asians who were part of the control groupi.e., they saw images of successful Black people in “counterstereotypical domains””drew an automatic inference that race was not a success-inhibiting factor in modern society.”

Subjects who were shown images of Black basketball players or singersmore “traditional” areas of African-American successwere not as likely to deny the existence of systemic racism.

Still, most participants said that their beliefs about race and discrimination would not change based on seeing a single Black person’s success. Critcher believes that this unconscious denial of racism affects economic and social policy, such as the recent push to eliminate affirmative action.

“The bias is insidious,” he said. “People weren’t even aware that their beliefs had shifted. That can make it even harder to correct.”

Racism is still very much alive in America, as DiversityInc readers know. And the workplace is not immune: A recent study showed that many employers avoid hiring Blacks because of the assumption that Blacks do drugs.

Latest News


Tennessee Lawmakers Move to Ban Education Against Racism in State’s Public Schools

In recent months, Republican-led states have already moved to enact racist and hyper restrictive voter registration laws, strip rights from LGBTQ individuals and attack trans students and their families — but their ongoing efforts to attack Democrats, populations of color and other diverse individuals don’t appear to be stopping there….

Latinx voting

New Study Reveals 1 Out of Every 10 Voters in 2020 Presidential Election was Latinx — a New Record in Representation

Thanks to extraordinary registration efforts and incredibly high turnout among younger and U.S.-born Hispanics, a new study conducted at the City University of New York has found that voting rates for Latinx men and women reached a new record high during the 2020 U.S. Presidential election. Suzanne Gamboa of NBC…

Mastercard building

Mastercard Commits $25 Million+ To Ensure Equitable Access to Vaccines Across the Globe, Partnering With Global Citizens VAX LIVE Campaign

Originally published at Mastercard ranked No. 5 on The DiversityInc Top 50 Companies for Diversity list in 2021.   COVID-19 has taken its toll in every region, every country and every community. The accessibility of vaccines and therapeutics are not ubiquitous across the globe, leaving vulnerable populations disadvantaged. Mastercard…

Marriott International building

Marriott International Named to DiversityInc Hall of Fame — The First and Only Hospitality Company To Achieve This Distinction

Originally published at Marriott International is a DiversityInc Hall of Fame company.   After leading the DiversityInc Top 50 Companies for Diversity list in 2020, Marriott International, Inc. was named to the DiversityInc Hall of Fame, as the first hospitality company joining previously number one ranked companies. DiversityInc announced this recognition on May…

Capital One: ‘Freedom To Be You’

Originally published at Capital One Financial ranked No. 28 on The DiversityInc Top 50 Companies for Diversity list in 2021.   Cindy Viener joined Capital One in 2009 and leads Product Management for several of its Card platforms, including Marketing, Rewards, Payments and Customer Resiliency. Viener has also served…

social media

GLAAD Declares Facebook, Instagram, TikTok, Twitter and YouTube ‘Effectively Unsafe’ for LGBTQ Users

In a first-of-its-kind report on “user experience” for the country’s leading social media platforms, the Gay & Lesbian Alliance Against Defamation (GLAAD) has declared Facebook, Instagram, TikTok, Twitter and YouTube “effectively unsafe for LGBTQ users.” Cynthia Silva from NBC News reported that GLAAD’s inaugural “Social Media Safety Index” report originally…