Study: Are Black Students in Integrated Schools Getting a Better Education Than Segregated Students

By Julissa Catalan


A new study confirms that racially segregated schooling is a disadvantage to young learners.

The study, conducted by the Frank Porter Graham Child Development Institute (FPG) at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, compiled data from the Department of Education in order to track the fluctuation in reading levels of first-graders, depending on whether they are enrolled in an integrated or segregated school.

“When the minority composition of schools was 75 percent or more, the growth in African-American first-graders’ reading skills lagged behind their African-American peers in more integrated schools,” said Kirsten Kainz, FPG’s Director of Statistics. “This alone wasn’t news. Numerous studies have shown how the performance of African-American students suffers in segregated schools.”

The researchers used nationwide data from the 199899 Early Childhood Longitudinal Study on close to 4,000 first-grade students in the public-school system.

Because “the economic, social and academic backgrounds of the students who attend segregated schools could be the cause of differences in achievementand not aspects of the segregated settings themselves,” Kainz used a statistical technique called “propensity score matching,” which specifically aims to measure reading growth in segregated and non-segregated schools, while also accounting for numerous differences in the child’s background.

After much research, Kainz determined that it was not a race-related circumstance, but rather the actual schooling.

“When similar groups of first-graders do better in one type of school than another, then it must be some aspect of the school that accounts for the difference,” Kainz said. “This study goes further than any other in being able to say, ‘It’s not the kids.'”

The study’s authors also point out that although their research accounts for the impact a teacher’s experience level might have on a student, it does not account for the broader effects high teacher turnover rates might have on segregated schools. Because of this, the study says, “it is important to consider alternative specifications of individual teacher experience and school-wide teacher experience as potential explanations for the negative effects of segregation on student achievement.”

“It may be that segregated schools affect African-American students in particular because these schools have fewer resources to devote to high-quality instruction, experience more teacher turnover, and are more likely to employ novice teachers,” Kainz explained. “In addition, the communities surrounding segregated schools may not have as many supports for reading development outside of the school day and year.”

“We found no reason to believe that the negative impact in first grade is a function of [Black students’] background characteristics,” Kainz told The Huffington Post. “It’s another piece of evidence that the context in which kids learn really matters. Local and national policies that want to launch kids in successful literacy directions should be attending to these contexts.”

Interestingly, the research also concluded that this trend did not apply to Latino or white students. Kainz has yet to determine a reason for this.

However, the study does reference other research on Latino students that indicates that school poverty might have a greater influence on the academic achievement of Latino learners, as opposed to a school’s racial structure.

Kainza Research Associate Professor of Education at UNChas studied effective education practices, especially for economically disadvantaged students.

“Many communities have direct local control over processes that can ensure they don’t inadvertently promote segregation,” she said, advising for segregated neighborhoods to utilize the resources available to them, such as residential planning.

Latest News

We, As Ourselves initiative

Tarana Burke, Founder of #MeToo Movement, Starts New Initiative for Black Survivors

When activist Tarana Burke coined the #MeToo movement, she knew it would start a culture-shifting conversation about sexual violence. But three years after that movement began, she believes that change hasn’t been as far-reaching as she’d hoped, especially for Black women who’ve faced some aspect of sexual abuse or violence. …

Thasunda Brown Duckett

Thasunda Brown Duckett Named CEO of TIAA; Second Black Woman Recently Named to Lead Fortune 500 Company

TIAA — Teachers Insurance and Annuity Association of America — has announced that Thasunda Brown Duckett will become the company’s new CEO, succeeding Roger W. Ferguson Jr. who announced in November 2020 his plans to retire. With her appointment, Duckett will join newly named Walgreen’s CEO Rosalind Brewer as one…

Black News Channel BNC

Cable News Expands to Include More Black Voices with Black News Channel

As the world of cable TV news becomes increasingly fragmented, BNC (Black News Channel) is promising to deliver an alternative news source that looks at breaking news stories through the eyes of Black Americans when it relaunches in March 2021. In a Wall Street Journal exclusive, reporter Lillian Rizzo writes…