close and back to page

Latest News

Latest News

Was Our Article on the SSM Hospital Beat Down 'Fair and Unbiased'?

An inquiry from a reader inspires further investigation and the results are shocking.

The following email came in from a Yahoo.com email address; I am not going to reveal the person's name:


To the editor,

I work with internal communications at a company lauded for excellence in diversity and write about our ERGs and diversity practices. I rely on DiversityInc for news, best practices and webinars that support diversity in the work force and in the community.

I am shocked, however, at the increased amount of biased news articles I'm reading. Maybe I've not been combing through the articles carefully enough; maybe I have a misplaced expectation for DiversityInc to provide balanced and unbiased reporting.

Here is an example from excerpts of a story posted on your site written by Keka Araujo about a horrible altercation at a hospital.

Albert Watkins, Allen's attorney, had some choice words to say concerning the attack:

"This was 220 pounds of white daytime TV muscle on top of her …You have a security guard

with an IQ well below room temperature taking it upon himself to see that 'justice' is

done to a 90-pound patient in distress."

The last paragraph:

Basically, the hospital glossed over their responsibility of hiring

an incompetent good old boy who allegedly assaulted one of their patients

and then adding insult to injury by filing charges against her. Got it.

Two things strike me – the article did not sufficiently explore both sides of the story; though it appeared there was just a press release from the hospital, there were no witness statements and the video doesn't show the full progression of the altercation.

Secondly, if the security guard had been an African American, the quote by the attorney and the author's last paragraph would be considered grossly prejudicial. Both the attorney and the reporter would, by today's standards, be vilified for being alarmingly inappropriate in their comments.

Diversity means equality and opportunity for ALL people, not free reign to slam any particular minority nor (in this article) the white community.

I'd like to think that I can expect proper, balanced reporting with DiversityInc news. This type of reporting is unacceptable.

Dear Ms. (redacted),

Thank you for your email.

I am responsible for all content on my website. I watched the video before I approved the article being written, I stand by my editor, the journalist who reports to her and the finished product. In my opinion, Keka's last paragraph summed it up perfectly.

"Bias" is an interesting adjective to assert in this situation. My bias is different than that hospital's CEO; I would have fired that guard, apologized to the victim and the community, and carefully considered firing the rest of the security guards and whoever was responsible for supervising them.

I'd be biased to assume that this wasn't the first time this "security guard" beat up a woman one-third his size — and that the monster's coworkers knew about the sadist and did nothing.

My hunch is the hospital CEO got "advice" from the white lawyer on her 93 percent white leadership team that doesn't have a single Black person, despite St. Louis being 49.2 percent Black (the majority demographic). Let's see, majority Black city, 93 percent white/0 percent Black hospital leadership team (72 percent male, in an industry dominated by women). Some might call that "bias." I call it racism — and sexism.

As far as race and coverage, we endeavor to cover news "from a colorful perspective" and I think we do. I am quite sure SSM could use a lot of help in getting a better perspective and St. Louis would be better served if they did.

Best regards,

Luke Visconti, CEO

The Conversation (6)
votetocorrect20 Oct, 2018

That was a serious beat down and the security guard needs to stand trial for feloneny battery!

Dawn19 Oct, 2018

Thank you for backing the story written by Keka Araujo. Too often people are afraid to tell it like it is. I am grateful that you and DiversityInc are not.

Sheri19 Oct, 2018

Thank you Mr. Visconti. I read your content daily and I appreciate you shining the light on racial injustices that plague our country.

Dee Dankus18 Oct, 2018

Mr. Visconti, you are not incorrect in your overall assessment of this incident, but DePaul Hospital is not in St. Louis City, which I suspect your demographic information is based on (i.e. St. Louis County has different demographics, though the other numbers you quote, if accurate, are still appalling). Your publication provides a necessary service, but "colorful perspective" still needs to be accurate.

Jim Acosta's Alleged 'Assault' of White House Intern Debated on 'The View'

"When you look at the clip, is that inappropriate touching? We know when someone is accused of assault, that's a very loaded word," said Whoopi Goldberg.

An intense debate on whether or not CNN reporter, Jim Acosta, "assaulted" a White House intern during a press conference with President Trump took place on ABC's morning talk show, "The View."

Read More Show Less

VIDEO: Patient Attacked at St. Louis Hospital by Security Guard

"220 pounds of white daytime TV muscle on top of her."

Vanity Allen went to the hospital for stomach pains and ended up being brutally assaulted by a hospital security guard in July.

Read More Show Less

Kavanaugh vs. Ford

A tale of a complete lack of diversity causing bad decisions, and shifting opinions nationwide, as well as a teachable moment for corporate America.

Having zero diversity, and by trying to make it "Kavanaugh vs. Ford," the old, white Republican men lost control of the nomination, and made it about them versus all women, a situation that, at best, will be a Pyrrhic victory.

Read More Show Less

An off-duty Miami Beach police officer and her sister brutally attacked a woman while she was on a date with her boyfriend. Ambar Pacheco kicked eight-months-pregnant, Evoni Murray, age 27, in the stomach and has been fired, police officials said. The attack sent Murray into premature labor.

Read More Show Less

Trump Continues to Disparage Women and Mocks #MeToo

His campaign tactic of offending others rallies his base.

REUTERS

At his Great Falls, Mont., rally yesterday, President Trump doled out insults to Rep. Maxine Waters, Sen. Elizabeth Warren, Hillary Clinton and survivors of sexual harassment and assault — as if he didn't care that his "grab 'em by the p***y" comments and assaults weren't part a catalyst for the movement.

Read More Show Less

Suck It Up, We’re Screwed

Decades of incompetent Democratic leadership — and disregard for diversity — has taken us down this path.

The retirement of Justice Anthony Kennedy puts our country at a crossroads where there's only one expected outcome: a bizarrely out of touch and unrepresentative Supreme Court, for generations to come.

Read More Show Less

White Racists Use Intimidation for Years to Beat Black Employee with Disability into Slavery

This week's guilty plea to federal charges says what many knew — this was calculated.

Horry County Sheriff's Department

Bobby Paul Edwards, 53, who was charged with slavery, assault and battery, false imprisonment, Fair Labor violations and discriminations against John Christopher Smith, a Black employee with intellectual disabilities at J&J Cafeteria in Myrtle Beach, S.C., plead guilty on Monday.

Read More Show Less

Starbucks’ Optional Diversity Training Empowers People like Roseanne

Clearly communicated policies and values build corporate diversity success — treating people right is not an option for a well-run company.

By making yesterday's diversity training optional, Starbucks revealed top management indecision about its own principles and how to treat customers.

Read More Show Less