Target Wins Right to Sell Rosa Parks Merchandise

Target (No. 25 on DiversityInc’s Top 50 Companies for Diversity) won a lawsuit last week against the Rosa and Raymond Parks Institute, allowing the company to continue selling Rosa Parks merchandise.


On Dec. 1, 1955, Rosa Parks was arrested when she refused to give up her seat on a bus to a white man. She continues to be celebrated as a heroine for civil rights in American history.

The Parks Institute, a non-profit organization based in Michigan, owns the name and likeness of Parks, who passed away on Oct. 24, 2005 at age 92.

Related Story: Rosa Parks: Spiritual Godmother to BLM

Target sells several pieces of merchandise honoring Parks’ memory, including several books about her, a television movie called “The Rosa Parks Story” and a plaque with a picture of Parks and Dr. Martin Luther King Jr.

Parks has been praised by Congress as the “first lady of civil rights” for her valiant efforts against racial injustices.

The Parks Institute, which filed the $20 million suit in 2013 in Alabama, claimed Target “used Rosa Parks'[s] name, likeness, and image to sell products and did promote and sell products using said name, likeness, and image for Defendant’s own commercial advantage.” None of the products contain any Target logos or branding.

Target pointed to a similar case that brought into question the sale of Tiger Woods posters winning the Masters because this was considered a “historic event in the world of sports” and Parks’ life symbolized significant importance in the Civil Rights movement.

“If the First Amendment interests in a golf tournament preclude the right of publicity liability for a poster about that tournament, the First Amendment interests in the Rosa Parks story preclude liability for a poster about that story and the story of the modern Civil Rights movement,” the corporation said.

Chief United States District Judge W. Keith Watkins agreed with the retailer, saying, “the Parks Institute is mistaken”:

“The depiction of Rosa Parks’s life story without the Parks Institute’s consent does not violate the Parks Institute’s ownership rights to Rosa Parks’s name or likeness,” the judge wrote in his ruling. “To quote from one of the biographical works at issue, ‘Rosa Parks is ‘perhaps the most iconic heroine of the civil rights movement.’ And, as both parties agree, one cannot talk about the Civil Rights movement without including Rosa Parks. The importance of her story serves as an apt reminder of why First Amendment protection for biographical works is so vital.”

Target won the first suit and the Parks Institute filed an appeal in Michigan. Circuit Judge Robin Rosenbaum last week came to the same ruling, saying that Parks’ life and memory are matters of public interest and people should have access to information about her life:

“The use of Rosa Parks’s name and likeness in the books, movie, and plaque is necessary to chronicling and discussing the history of the Civil Rights Movement matters quintessentially embraced and protected by Michigan’s qualified privilege,” the judge wrote. “Indeed, it is difficult to conceive of a discussion of the Civil Rights Movement without reference to Parks and her role in it. As a result, all six books, the movie, and the plaque find protection in Michigan’s qualified privilege protecting matters of public interest.”

Parks: A Powerful Woman Then and Now

The plaque sold by Target features the word “CHANGE,” as well as a quote from Parks: “People always say that I didn’t give up my seat because I was tired, but that isn’t true. I was not tired physically I was not old I was forty-two. No, the only tired I was, was tired of giving in.”

Despite common folklore portraying Parks as a frail, quiet old woman, she was actually a “seasoned activist,” Dr. Adolphus Belk Jr. told DiversityInc in a recent interview. Belk, a political science professor, serves as the director of the African American Studies Program at Winthrop University. He recently spoke on MSNBC about issues regarding Black women voters.

“[Parks] didn’t just fail to move because she was too tired to comply,” Belk explained. “She wasn’t this sort of delicate, passionate person in it all. She had a great deal of agency. She had a lot of fire. She was someone who had a strong mind, who had a long commitment to civil justice and civil rights. And who had already been a leader in the NAACP in Montgomery.”

Belks also told DiversityInc that he sees similarities between the battle fought by Parks and the activism going on now in the Black Lives Matter movement, saying that criticisms of the BLM movement “sort of harken back to the things that people said during the mid-to-late 1960s about the civil rights movement itself.”

“So in some ways we’re watching the same film,” he explained.

In her ruling, Judge Rosenbaum also highlighted Parks’ bravery and her importance in American history as well as today.

“Parks’s refusal to cede ground in the face of continued injustice has made her among the most revered heroines of our national history; her role in American history cannot be over-emphasized,” she said.

Latest News

Humana

Humana, Quantified Ventures, and Volunteers of America Partner to Establish First of Its Kind Health Outcomes Fund

Originally published on Humana.com  The new fund will help Volunteers of America sustainably scale Family Focused Recovery program operations to provide comprehensive services to mothers with substance use disorder and their children Humana Inc. (NYSE: HUM) today re-confirms its commitment to provide innovative models of care for families through a…

AOC celebrates a victory in Among Us during her Twitch stream

AOC Livestreamed ‘Among Us’ on Twitch to Encourage Everyone (but Particularly Young People) to Vote

New York congresswoman Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (AOC) is stepping up Democratic efforts to make sure young voters are prepared when heading to the polls on Election Day, especially in light of COVID-19. On Oct. 21, 2020, AOC livestreamed on Twitch to engage with the younger demographic that frequents the video game-centric…

Black Lives Matter face mask for preventing spread of COVID-19

BLM T-shirts and Trump Masks Cause Uproar at Early Polling Locations; New Credit Cards Allow Trans Individuals to Use Preferred Name; and More

BLM T-shirts and Trump masks cause uproar at early polling locations. Voters’ choice of clothing when heading to the polls in Florida and Tennessee has begun making headlines across the country. The Washington Post reported that Miami police officer Daniel Ubeda has come under fire for wearing a Trump-endorsing face…

Enjoy Chic Comfort at the Newly Opened Hilton Mall of Istanbul

Originally published on Hilton.com Hilton Mall of Istanbul, located within Turkey’s largest shopping and entertainment center, offers 175 guest rooms including 14 suites, extensive conference facilities and easy access from the new Istanbul Airport Today Hilton Mall of Istanbul opens its doors to guests. The world-class 175-room hotel, located within the same…

Close-up image of COVID-19 virus

Black and Latinx Individuals Increasingly Worried About Impact of COVID-19 on Career; Potential Spike in New Disabilities Due to Pandemic; and More

More than 50% of Blacks and Latinx individuals significantly worried about finances and career prospects due to pandemic. COVID-19 continues to be top of mind for most of the country, especially as cases appear to be worsening in our current third wave of the illness. But a new survey of…

Rep. Jahana Hayes (D-Conn.)

Rep. Jahana Hayes Attacked in Racist Campaign Town Hall; 1 in 4 Americans Unemployed According to New Data from Axios; and More

Racist trolls interrupt Zoom town hall hosted by Jahana Hayes, Connecticut’s first Black congresswoman. “I am not OK,” wrote Rep. Jahana Hayes (D-Conn.) in a moving post describing a violent attack that took place at one of her recent campaign events. Ten minutes into the Zoom town hall for one…