The New Motivation For Hate Crimes

Race is no longer the number one bias behind hate crimes. What is and how many hate crimes occur every year?

By Chris Hoenig

Ethnicity has replaced race as the No. 1 bias behind hate crimes, according to an analysis of data from the Bureau of Justice Statistics (BJS).

In 51 percent of the estimated 293,800 nonfatal violent and property hate crimes in 2012, the victims reported ethnicity—defined as the victim's ancestral, cultural, social or national affiliation—as the bias that motivated the crime. Race was the second-most-common bias, motivating 46 percent of hate crimes. Approximately 58 percent of hate-crime victims reported more than one bias behind the crimes they suffered.

The rise in ethnically motivated hate crimes is a marked change from 2004, when 58 percent said race was the reason they were victimized. Ethnicity was the bias for 22 percent of the crimes in 2012, the most recent year that data are available, tied with sexual orientation as the third-most-common motivation behind race and association (perceived as the offender's bias by 23 percent of victims).

Association now sits as the third most common bias (34 percent), followed by religion, which nearly tripled from 10 percent in 2004 to 28 percent in 2012, and gender, which more than doubled to 26 percent from 12 percent in 2004.

In addition to race, sexual orientation has seen a drop as the motivation for hate crimes, going from 22 percent in 2004 to 13 percent of hate crimes in 2012, as has perceived association (dropping from 19 percent to 7 percent). Crimes motivated by a person's disability were steady at 11 percent.

The most common form of hate crime was simple assault, which occurred 63 percent of the time. About 90 percent were violent crimes, up from 78 percent in 2004, and 27 percent were classified as serious violent crimes, which includes rape or sexual assault, robbery and aggravated assault.

The BJS estimates about 60 percent of hate crimes were not reported to police in 2012, though there is little statistically significant difference from the number of hate crimes that occurred in 2004 (281,700). These make up 1.2 percent of total victimizations and 4.2 percent of all violent crimes in 2012.

Only 22 percent of hate crimes were reported by the actual victim, while 12 percent were reported by someone else. Complaints were signed in 13 percent of the cases, while only an estimated 4 percent of hate crimes resulted in an arrest. In at least a quarter of the crimes the offender had a weapon, and the victim was injured in one out of every five cases.

Latinos were more than twice as likely as whites to be the victims of hate crimes—a rate that is more than triple what it was for Latinos in 2011—while Blacks were the second most likely. Men and women were victimized at a nearly equal rate, though nearly half of all victims were under the age of 25. Low-income individuals, with a household income under $25,000, were more than twice as likely to be victimized as any other income bracket.

The most-common offenders were men (61 percent), who were over 30 (41 percent) and who acted alone (64 percent). A virtually even number of offenders were white (34 percent) and Black (32 percent), while a slight majority (53 percent) had an intimate, familial or casual relationship with the victim.

The BJS tracks hate crimes using the National Crime Victimization Survey (NCVS) and the Hate Crime Statistics Act (HCSA). The HCSA defines a hate crime as "crimes that manifest evidence of prejudice based on race, religion, sexual orientation or ethnicity," and was amended to include people with disabilities in 1994 and gender or gender identity in 2009.

Golf Club Calls Police on Black Women Members for Allegedly Playing Too Slow

The five women, one a local NAACP president, say it's a clear case of racial and gender discrimination.

Myneca Ojo / FACEBOOK

Five Black women, members of the Grandview Golf Club in Braddock, the oldest public golf course in York County, Pa., decided to meet on Saturday for a round of golf. The outing ended with the club co-owner, who is white, calling the police on the only Black, female players on the course because they allegedly played too slow and did not want to cancel their membership and leave.

Read More Show Less

Blacks Much More Likely to Be Stopped Indoors in Philly Than Whites

Starbucks needs a corporate culture makeover — but it is not the only party at fault.

The arrest of two Black men who asked to use the bathroom at a Starbucks in Philadelphia was not an anomaly, according to a new analysis, further suggesting that a half-day implicit bias training is not likely to bring any actionable solutions.

Read More Show Less

Waffle House Shooter: White Affirmative Action Strikes Again

Blacks are disproportionately killed, while guns are given back to the Waffle House shooter, despite concerns about his mental health issues and previous violent threats.

Travis Reinking / REUTERS

The Waffle House shooter had his guns taken away and given back to him, and the question is whether or not that would've happened if Travis Reinking was Black. His father, who ultimately was given the guns back by the police, promised to keep the weapons secure and out of his son's possession, according to Southern California Public Radio's report. Both the father and the police were aware of Reinking's history of mental instability, but chose to give Reinking another chance.

Read More Show Less

Syracuse University Expels Fraternity over 'Racist, Sexist' Video

"The racist, anti-Semitic, homophobic, ableist and sexist video was part of a Theta Tau sponsored event," Chancellor Kent Syverud said.


(Reuters) — Syracuse University has permanently expelled a fraternity after a video surfaced this week showing its members using racist and offensive terms in a skit the chapter said was satirical, a school official said on Saturday.

Read More Show Less

Religious Faith Linked to Suicidal Behavior in LGBQ Adults

Although religiosity is generally tied to reduced suicide risk, the opposite may be true for some young lesbian, gay and questioning adults.

(Reuters ) — Although religiosity is generally tied to reduced suicide risk, the opposite may be true for some young lesbian, gay and questioning adults, researchers say.

Read More Show Less

Firefighter Charged for Spitting on Black Toddler, Using the N-word Gets Job Back

It's not surprising as a Black firefighter once sued the Kansas City Fire Department for discrimination.

Terrence Jeremy Skeen, a 15-year veteran of the Kansas City Fire Department who spat on a 3-year-old Black boy and called him the n-word, has got his job back.

Read More Show Less

Three LA Fitness Employees Immediately Fired for Racism

Unlike Starbucks, LA Fitness makes the right move and terminates the employees responsible.


Three employees at an LA Fitness in Secaucus, N.J., were terminated after they were accused of harassing two Black men who were simply trying to work out.

Read More Show Less