New York Times Does It Again: The 'Angry Black Woman'

By Daryl Hannah

The New York Times either doesn’t get it or doesn’t care. Just weeks after publishing a poorly balanced profile of Michael Brown, the 18-year-old fatally shot by Ferguson Police Officer Darren Wilson in July, the paper is again facing a national outcry from readers who are furious over the paper’s use of racial epithets to describe African-American women.

A Sunday profile of television writer and producer Shonda Rhimes by Times Culture Critic Alessandra Stanley opened with “When Shonda Rhimes writes her autobiography, it should be called ‘How to Get Away With Being an Angry Black Woman'” and ended with an angry-black-woman joke linking Rhimes and First Lady Michelle Obama. In between was a mix of compliments and slights about Rhimes’ ability to navigate the overwhelmingly white and patriarchal media industry.

“Ms. Rhimes has embraced the trite but persistent caricature of the Angry Black Woman, recast it in her own image and made it enviable,” Stanley wrote in her article. “She has almost single-handedly trampled a taboo even Michelle Obama couldn’t break.

Rhimes earlier responded to Stanley’s characterization of her as “angry” with the candor most who follow her on social media have come to expect:

The story quickly spread across social media and prompted responses from some of Rhimes’ star actors who were together celebrating the kick-off of Rhimes’ new show. When asked by The Hollywood Reporter how they would describe Rhimes, Kerry Washington, Viola Davis and Chandra Wilson used the adjectives brilliant, compassionate, courageous, innovative, shy and visionary.

It also didn’t take long for online petitions to pop up demanding the Times apologize for the offensive article. Civil-rights organization launched a national petition calling on the paper to retract the article but provided no information on how many people had signed the petition.

“Characterizing their supreme confidence and competence as ‘anger’and describing actress Viola Davis as sexy ‘in a slightly menacing way’ and ‘darker-skinned and less classically beautiful’only plays into destructive stereotypes that impact the lives of Black women every day,” an email blast to’s 900,000 members read. “Alessandra Stanley and The New York Times need to know that the dissemination and perpetuation of the ‘angry Black women’ archetype is no laughing matter. With so few Black women both onscreen or behind the scenes in Hollywood, high-profile, dehumanizing misinterpretations of their work cannot be tolerated.”

On Monday, Times Public Editor Margaret Sullivan used her Public Editor’s Journal to address the growing disdain for the article and questioned its deftness.

The readers and commentators are correct to protest this story,” Sullivan wrote. “Intended to be in praise of Ms. Rhimes, it delivered that message in a condescending way that wasat bestastonishingly tone-deaf and out of touch.”

The paper’s Culture Editor Danielle Mattoon also apologized for Stanley’s article, saying: “There was never any intent to offend anyone and I deeply regret that it did. Alessandra used a rhetorical device to begin her essay, and because the piece was so largely positive, we as editors weren’t sensitive enough to the language being used. This is a signal to me that we have to constantly remind ourselves as editors of our blind spots, what we don’t know, and of how readers may react.”

It’s obvious that “blind spot” is the lack of diversity in the paper’s Culture department.

“I still plan to talk to [Dean Baquet, the newspaper’s Executive Editor] about the article, its editing, and about diversity in the newsroom, particularly among culture critics,” Sullivan wrote. “The Times has significant diversity among its high-ranking editors and prominent writers, but it’s troubling that with 20 critics, not one is Black and only two are persons of color.”

“Of approximately 1,100 full time journalists at The New York Times (includes reporters, editors, producers, copy editors, etc), 19.5 percent are minorities and 41.7 percent are women,” a Times spokeswoman told DiversityInc when pressed for the numbers of Blacks and Black women on the paper’s editorial staff. “We do not break out our stats beyond those demographics.”

The Times does not participate in the DiversityInc Top 50 survey and declined to provide additional comment on the column about Rhimes.

New York City’s population is approximately two-thirds Black, Latino or Asian.

Latest News

Southern Company Commits $700,000 To Advance Racial Equity and Social Justice for the AAPI Community

Originally published at Southern Company ranked No. 20 on The DiversityInc Top 50 Companies for Diversity list in 2021.   The Southern Company Gas Charitable Foundation is announcing plans to donate $700,000 across its service territories to charities in support of improving equity and social justice. On the six-month…

Oak Park, Illinois

Illinois Professor Suspended, Charged with Hate Crime After Allegedly Spitting on Black Woman and Using Racial Slur

An Illinois professor has been suspended from his job and charged with a hate crime after he allegedly spat on and racially attacked a Black female driver in a suburban Chicago grocery store parking lot earlier this month. Antonio Planas of NBC News has reported that Alberto Friedmann, a professor…

Joaquin Castro

New Research Shows a Continued Lack of Hispanic and Latinx Representation in Movies, Media and Publishing

In a bit of disheartening news in the midst of Hispanic Heritage Month, a new government study has confirmed that Latinx individuals are vastly under-included and underrepresented in many parts of the media world. Astrid Galvan of the Associated Press reported on the study from the U.S. Government Accountability Office,…

Newberg, Oregon

Oregon School Employee Suspended for Showing Up to Work in Blackface To Protest State Vaccination Policies

Racial controversies continue to mount at the Newberg Public School system located in the suburbs of Portland, Oregon. Last week, students in the district’s high school conducted a mock “slave auction” on social media in which they ridiculed fellow classmates and discussed how much they would or wouldn’t pay to…