Crenshaw, intersectionality, workplace
Dr. Kimberlé Crenshaw — the feminist scholar and law professor at Columbia University who coined the term intersectionality — delivered the Women of Color and Their Allies speech Oct. 2.

Dr. Kimberlé Crenshaw Delivers Keynote Speech on Intersectionality

Dr. Kimberlé Crenshaw coined the phrase “intersectionality” nearly three decades ago, despite it only recently entering mainstream conversation. Crenshaw delivered the keynote speech Oct. 2 at DiversityInc’s Women of Color and Their Allies event, explaining the term intersectionality and its application to women of color in the workplace.

She coined the phrase in the ’90s to explain and address challenges Black women face as part of two disenfranchised demographics — both race and gender — simultaneously. During her keynote, Crenshaw described intersectionality as a frame to expand understanding of systemic bias and discrimination. She said how a problem is framed dictates how to best go about solving it.

The term intersectionality, she said, was a metaphor to help people understand one can exist between two forms of oppression. For example, a Black woman can exist at the intersection of racial and gender discrimination and cannot attribute oppression against her as solely on the basis of her race or sex.

“What should we call this problem when first you’re impacted by two somewhat distinct exclusionary forces, and second, the ‘ambulance,’ the fix, the remedy, isn’t prepared to deal with the complexity of what hits you?”

She gave an anecdote from her time at Harvard Law School: in trying to get more women and people of color tenured as professors at the institution, the diverse student body demanded more representation. The university created a women’s committee and a minority committee. However, the women of color, simultaneously fitting into both categories, slipped through the cracks and felt represented in neither.

“It emerged that the assumption was that women of color rested within the purview of the other committee,” Crenshaw said. “My question was how was it that this so obvious problem escaped the attention of everyone? That a committee dealing with race but not gender, or a committee dealing with gender and not race, was clearly inadequate in realizing the institutional commitment to race and gender diversity?”

In studying law to try to understand this phenomenon, Crenshaw came across the case, Emma DeGraffenreid v. G.M., in which DeGraffenreid sued for both race and gender discrimination for being denied a job. All of the African Americans the company hired were men, and all of the women were white.

The court ruling allowed DeGraffenreid to claim both forms of discrimination would offer her “two swings at the bat,” and, therefore, preferential treatment.

“If the judge had actually looked at the ways that these two patterns of hiring, these two practices, came together, he would’ve seen that Black women were falling through the cracks,” Crenshaw said. “They were facing not just race discrimination and not just gender discrimination. They were facing double discrimination. Discrimination within discrimination.”

Crenshaw explained the “but for” phenomenon. If white, straight, cisgender, heterosexual men have the most power, many have the ability to say they, too, could have such power, “but for” a single trait. For example, a white woman could say she could have the position “but for” her gender, and a Black man could say he’d have the position “but for” his race. Others who have intersectionally-oppressed identities have more than one single aspect that disadvantages them. DeGraffenreid lost her case because the judge said she could not make a single claim of discrimination.

“But some people, those who are not just one ‘but for’ away from white men, they can’t use this particular approach,” Crenshaw said. “Black women were not in the same position as Black men and white women to make the ‘but for’ command.”

Crenshaw pointed out the issue with women of color’s lack of representation in the C-suite as a unique problem. She cited a recent McKinsey & Company study that showed women of color are underrepresented on each level in corporate pipelines. The study suggests part of this dilemma is caused by the fact that women of color are the least likely to receive support from those above them.

With white men being most commonly situated in positions of power, it is difficult for women of color to seek them out as mentors. Without a schema for these men to use as a guideline to interact with women of color, women of color appear unfamiliar and thus struggle to make connections with powerful higher-ups.

“Whether true or not, the very perception of greater difference may be underscored by the fact that there are fewer analogies, fewer zones of the familiar that women of color can use to navigate workplace differences with powerful mentors.”

Crenshaw said understanding the complexity and reality of intersectionality is the key to addressing discrimination against women of color.

“When looking at any interventions, when you know there’s still a problem, it’s important to ask how this problem might affect some people differently than others,” Crenshaw said. “That’s what intersectionality asks us to do.”

Related Story: HBR Study Finds Workplace ‘Inclusion’ is Not Enough to Help Women of Color Feel Supported

Latest News

feinstein, northwell

Northwell Health’s Feinstein Institutes Teams Up with Sanofi, Regeneron Pharmaceuticals, Gilead Sciences to Test COVID-19 Treatments

The research arm of Northwell Health (No. 2 on DiversityInc’s 2019 Top Hospitals & Health Systems), the Feinstein Institutes for Medical Research, is partnering with Gilead Sciences, Regeneron Pharmaceuticals and Sanofi (No. 31 on DiversityInc’s 2019 Top 50 Companies for Diversity) to identify treatments for people hospitalized with moderate to severe…

EY Named a Leader in Managed Security Services and Professional Security Services in Asia-Pacific in Two Studies by IDC

Originally posted on EY.com EY is a leader in Asia-Pacific professional security services among 17 vendors EY has been recognized by IDC as a leader in two of its studies: IDC MarketScape: Asia/Pacific Managed Security Services 2020 Vendor Assessment, and IDC MarketScape: Asia/Pacific Professional Security Services – Advisory, Assessment, and Awareness 2020…

March 2020 ADP National Employment Report®, ADP Small Business Report® and ADP National Franchise Report® to be Released on Wednesday, April 1, 2020

Originally posted on ADP.com : ADP Research Institute® will release the March findings of the ADP National Employment Report, ADP Small Business Report and ADP National Franchise Report on Wednesday, April 1, 2020 at 8:15 a.m. ET. Due to the important contribution that small businesses make to economic growth, ADP Research Institute issues the ADP Small Business Report independently of the ADP National Employment Report. …

hiring

Companies Hiring Amid COVID-19 Crisis

Filings for unemployment insurance have risen to an unprecedented 2.3 million due to the COVID-19 crisis. Less than two weeks ago, that number was at 281,000 — which was already alarmingly close to the 299,000 previous record in 2017. Though unemployment rates have surged more than eight times the country’s…

Combatting Human Trafficking: How Hilton and Marriott Address a Global Human Rights Issue

It is estimated that anywhere from 20 to 40 million people are trapped in modern slavery worldwide. The fragmented, transient and relatively anonymous nature of hotels has made them critical sites for the trafficking of humans — typically for forced labor or sexual exploitation. But the hospitality industry has taken…

EY COVID-19 Business Continuity Plan: Five Ways to Reshape

Originally posted on EY LinkedIn and  EY.com  EY Responding to COVID-19 COVID-19 is an unfolding event bringing uncertainty to every business. To help you navigate through these unprecedented times, here you’ll find the most relevant EY insights on responding to volatility and building enterprise resilience. Global companies have to be predictive…

Wells Fargo Announces Aid for Customers and Communities Impacted by COVID-19

Comprehensive response includes suspending residential foreclosure sales, fee waivers and acceleration of $175 million in donations to help the most vulnerable Originally published on newsroom.wf.com. Wells Fargo & Company (NYSE: WFC) today announced additional comprehensive steps to help customers, communities and employees grappling with the impact of COVID-19. The company…

Cox Commits up to $5M for COVID-19 Testing

Originally posted on Cox.com The James M. Cox Foundation announced its commitment to provide up to $5 million to Emory Healthcare for purchasing COVID-19 testing equipment. In response to the coronavirus crisis, Emory and Cox are taking the lead with significant action to support the community. The equipment is currently…