Subscribe

login / sign up

close and back to page

Latest News

Latest News

Governor Considering Cyntoia Brown's Bid for Clemency

A Black Lives Matter member confronted Tennessee Gov. Bill Haslam, who only has six weeks left in office, making the case for Brown's clemency. Lawmakers are advocating for her as well.

Tennessee Gov. Bill Haslam has said he is considering the clemency request for Cyntoia Brown, a sex trafficking victim who was sentenced to life in prison for killing a man who picked her up for sex when she was a teen. The adept questioning of a member of Black Lives Matter Nashville prompted Haslam's statement.


At a higher education event on Monday, while Haslam was delivering remarks, Justin Laing pressed him about a recent ruling. Last week, the Tennessee Supreme Court said Brown must serve at least 51 years in prison before she could be released.

"Since we're here talking about education, I wanted to ask a question about one of your students and graduates of Lipscomb University, Cyntoia Brown," said Laing, who is also a higher education professional.

The audience began to applaud.

"Cyntoia Brown is currently serving year 14 of a life sentence for the murder of Johnny Allen, a 43-year-old who purchased her for sex at the age of 16. Cyntoia was acting in self-defense as Allen was attempting to assault her. As a victim of sex trafficking and assault, this is an unjust sentence in the first place.

"According to Tennessee laws, a teenager cannot be considered a prostitute. Cyntoia was 16, therefore she was a minor, and at any point, any sexual encounter cannot be considered consensual. Tennessee also ruled that all minors engaged in sex work are considered victims of trafficking. However, she has not been treated as a victim of trafficking and not given the justice that she deserves."

Laing added that Brown having to serve 51 years before parole is a "human rights issue."

"And so I ask you, what really, functionally, is the difference between life without parole — which is no longer constitutional as the United States Supreme Court declared for minors, for any crime — and 'you might get parole after 51 years' for a victim of sex trafficking?" he said.

The moderator attempted to interrupt Laing, but he continued to question the governor.

"And so I ask why has Cyntoia Brown been incarcerated for 14 years for enduring harm? And so I say Gov. Haslam, you have the power and ability to grant clemency to Cyntoia Brown, and so I ask when will you grant her clemency, I ask what will be your legacy as you leave office, and how will you answer to this human rights violation that the state of Tennessee is committing by keeping her incarcerated?"

Haslam thanked Laing for his question. He said the Supreme Court ruling doesn't "impact what we do at all."

"We are in the middle of reviewing it," he added. "I will say this — we're reviewing a lot of cases, and while Cyntoia's case has gotten a lot of publicity, I don't think you want us to treat hers any different than a whole lot of cases that I think people want us to review to see if it's been handled well."

In regard to a time frame for a decision, he said, "I'm just here for six more weeks, so it will be before that."

A MoveOn.org petition has garnered almost 600,000 electronic signatures from people who support Brown's release.

Incoming U.S. Representative Ayanna Pressley said, in an Instagram post on Tuesday, that Brown's sentencing is "unjust."

"I will work with my colleagues in Congress to bring awareness to this issue and end the systemic criminalization of survivors worldwide. #believesurvivors"

Click here for information on how you can contact Tennessee Gov. Bill Haslam.

Reader Question: Sex and labor trafficking in the U.S. remains a major problem. Why do you think it isn't being addressed effectively?

The Conversation (5)
Dandy Philkastel13 Dec, 2018

The Donald Trump Syndrome has also consumed the courts of Law. Which country in the World punish the victimized? Which countries in the World allow injustices like this? This is wicked and evil and the judge who made this ruling needs to exchange places with this victim.

Charlotte Henderson13 Dec, 2018

There are probably lots of reasons from out-and-out bigotry to disinterest and preoccupation. However, victims often don't have the financial or emotional resources to press their defense effectively. Without competent advocacy, they can be overwhelmed and the "system" victimizes them all over again. In this case, the victim should never have been charged with murder in the first place. The "system" should start making sure criminal charges are brought according to law and in view of mitigating circumstances.

votetocorrect13 Dec, 2018
Gov. Bill Haslam grant clemency to Brown!
Tracy Brooks25 Dec, 2018

This is and always will be the American way this young lady had the misfortune of not only being victimized by a sexual diviant whom happened to to be white but also getting caught up in americas corrupt system of injustice while wearing BLACK skin.

If this governor does the right thing for this young lady it will be because of some favor he will gain from a third party or another crooked politician the back room deals we hear so much about it definitely want be because he believes sparring one black life unjustified pain and confinement is the right thing to do.

Dawn15 Dec, 2018

Look at who is in charge in America. Look at who has all of the power. The majority of white male creatures think only of themselfs. Who are the worst offenders of sex crimes? We all know that the majority of serial killers are white men. It's way past time for this country to have someone other than white men in power. I am so angry that that poor girl had to go through being a sex slave, and then the very people who should have been there to save and protect her, put her in jail.

Black Student in Kansas Sues School District for Racial Discrimination

The dance team's choreographer told Camille Sturdivant that her skin was "too dark" to perform because she "clashed" with uniforms.

Camille Sturdivant and coaches Kevin Murakami and Carley Fine

Camille Sturdivant has filed a racial discrimination lawsuit against the Blue Valley School District for the abuse she was subjected to as a member of the high school dance team.

Read More Show Less

Cardi B. Delivers a More Effective Speech About Trump's Shutdown on Instagram Than Politicians

"Our country is in a hellhole right now," she said. "All for a f‐‐‐ing wall."

Rapper Cardi B. told her 39 million Instagram followers on Wednesday night what she really thought about President Trump's partial government shutdown, his wall and about his absurd request to force people who aren't getting paid to go back to work.

She didn't mince words (she uses explicit language in the video).

Read More Show Less

Five Cops Fired, Two Suspended After Man in Custody Died

"I can't breathe," Christopher Lowe said before he died. But officers still failed to call for help.

The Fort Worth Police Department has terminated five officers and suspended two for their involvement in the death of Christopher Lowe, 55, while he was in police custody last July.

Read More Show Less

Vermont Continues to Fail Black Legislator Racially Harassed By White Nationalist

Kiah Morris resigned from her position because of the harassment, but Vermont's attorney general said he will not file charges against the perpetrators, including Max Misch.

Kiah Morris was the only Black woman in the Vermont House of Representatives, until she resigned from her position in September, after enduring years of racially motivated harassment.

Read More Show Less

Trump's Government Shutdown Closes MLK Historic Sites

Ebenezer Baptist Church and most of the Martin Luther King Jr. National Historical Park in Atlanta are closed. "I feel a bit of sadness...I didn't expect to cry over this," said Bernice King.

Tuesday was Martin Luther King Jr.'s birthday and next Monday is our national celebration of the civil rights icon.

But school field trips, celebrations, families' visits to teach children about civil rights and the values of all people being created equally are being canceled due to President Trump's government shutdown.

Thousands of people who flock to Ebenezer Baptist Church in Atlanta, where Martin Luther King Jr. was pastor, and to his home, as well as the Smithsonian National Museum of African American History and Culture in D.C., will be disappointed. They are all closed.

Read More Show Less

Roku Pulls Racist 'Infowars' After Social Media Backlash

Alex Jones, founder of Infowars, has also been accused of sexual harassment. He allegedly grabbed a Black employee's backside saying: "Who wouldn't want a Black wife?"

Reuters

Six months after major social media channels such as YouTube and Twitter banned Alex Jones' Infowars, Roku, a streaming service, added a channel for the show's 24 million users. Apparently, there has been a channel for the show on Roku for years, according to Roku spokesman Eric Savitz.

Read More Show Less