chestnut, watkins, stewart, Baltimore, men exonerated
City prosecutor Marilyn Mosby spoke at the Baltimore women's march in 2018. She has been committed to the exoneration of those wrongly convicted since she took office in 2015. (Photo credit: 186.Rally1.WomensMarch.BaltimoreMD.20January2018 (28152267939) by Elvert Barnes, CC BY-SA 2.0)

Baltimore Men Alfred Chestnut, Ransom Watkins, Andrew Stewart Exonerated 36 Years After They Were Wrongly Convicted

Three men now walk free after being exonerated for a crime they spent 36 years in prison for. Alfred Chestnut, Ransom Watkins and Andrew Stewart, now in their 50s, were just 16 when they were wrongfully convicted of fatally shooting Baltimore middle schooler DeWitt Duckett over his Georgetown University jacket. They were sentenced to life in prison.

Chestnut, Watkins and Stewart had maintained their innocence over the decades, and on Monday Baltimore Circuit Court Judge Charles J. Peters declared them innocent.

Chestnut had advocated for his and his childhood friends’ release for years. This spring, the Baltimore City state’s attorney’s office’s Conviction Integrity Unit began investigating his claim and found a flawed case driven by the encouragement of false witness testimony and denial of another viable assailant.

Chestnut had seen city prosecutor Marilyn Mosby on television discussing the Conviction Integrity Unit, so he wrote a letter to her office asking for the team to review his case. He included new evidence he’d uncovered last year that incriminated, Michael Willis, the then-18-year-old authorities now say was the actual shooter. The unit reinterviewed witnesses.

Related Article: District Attorneys to Begin Visiting Prisons, Jails Regularly

Donald Kincaid, the lead investigator in the case, faces accusations that his and his police force’s investigation into the attack was coercive, but he denies there were improprieties in the investigation. Chestnut, Watkins and Stewart, then in high school, had skipped class that day and visited their middle school to goof around and say hello to siblings and old teachers. Police later found a Georgetown University jacket — which had no blood or other physical evidence suggesting it was Duckett’s — in Chestnut’s bedroom.

Kincaid told The Washington Post it was three girls who told him Watkins, Chestnut and Stewart had committed the crime. That information opened the case.

“When I was in the crime scene up at the school three young girls approached me and told me who did it,” Kincaid told the Post. “I didn’t coerce them for nothing. They passed the information to me, that’s what opened up the case.”

He also told the Post he did not remember Willis being a suspect and said he did not withhold information.

The teens had reportedly been kicked out of the middle school at 12:45 p.m., a half an hour before the shooting at 1:15 p.m., and the security guard said in his witness testimony that he scolded the boys and watched them walk away from the school as he locked the doors. Prosecutors insisted they must have somehow snuck back in.

Police documents show witnesses implicating Willis and failing to identify Chestnut, Watkins and Stewart in a lineup. During the trial, defense attorneys fought for evidence that cast doubt on the three boys’ guilt, but then-Assistant State’s Attorney Jonathan Shoup said there was no evidence.

Teenage witnesses were repeatedly questioned without their parents present and likely felt pressured to accuse Chestnut, Watkins and Stewart. Mosby said she is fighting to establish laws that prevent children from being questioned without a parent, guardian or attorney present. Witnesses have since recanted their testimonies, but Kincaid denies they were pressured into their accusations.

Furthermore, two witnesses said Willis was the shooter and one picked him out of a photo lineup. Another said they saw Willis run from the school and throw away a gun. None of this evidence was given to the defense.

Willis had a number of arrests on drug and assault charges following the Duckett shooting. He was fatally shot in West Baltimore in 2002 at 37.

Maryland does not have a system to financially compensate exonerees, but the state does allow it. Mosby said she would lobby for a system to compensate those exonerated. Chestnut, Watkins and Stewart have not publicly commented on whether they will seek monetary compensation.

Watkins, Stewart and Chestnut are the seventh, eighth and ninth exonerations Mosby’s Conviction Integrity Unit has led since she took office in 2015.

Related Story: Americans Prefer Life in Prison Over Death Penalty for Murder, Poll Shows

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

Latest News

As Change Accelerates, Insurers Need Profound Transformation and the Right Talent, Reveals EY Insurance Outlook 2020

Originally posted on EY.com Declining interest rates, changing customer expectations and shifting demographics are defining the future of insurance Insurers must strike the right balance between achieving operational excellence and investing in technology-led innovation As insurance industry growth remains stagnant for another year due to low interest rates, the shifts…

Accenture Named a Leader in Automated Life Insurance Underwriting Systems by Independent Research Firm

Originally posted on Accenture.com Accenture has been named a leader in automated life insurance underwriting systems in a new report from independent research firm Forrester. In the report — “The Forrester Wave™: Automated Life Insurance Underwriting Systems, Q4 2019”[1] — Accenture was named a leader based on the current offering and…

The Hershey Company: Joining Forces to Protect Human Rights

Originally published on thehersheycompany.com by Allison Arbib, Research Program Director at Verité, an independent, nonprofit, civil society organization focused on human rights and eliminating labor abuses.  In a range of human rights and labor rights due diligence frameworks — the UN Guiding Principles, the United States Department of Labor Comply Chain, the…

Comcast Launches Customer Service Program for the Deaf Community in American Sign Language

Originally Published on Comcast.com Comcast and Connect Direct, a subsidiary of Communication Service for the Deaf (CSD), today launched customer service support via American Sign Language (ASL) for Internet Essentials, Xfinity Internet, and general Xfinity billing questions, called ASL Now. With the combined expertise of both companies, Internet Essentials and…