court, Anesthesiologists, disability
A Tennessee nurse-anesthesiologist said she was fired because her employers believed her eyesight made her unable to do her job. Her employers claim it was because she committed errors. The U.S. Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals has reinstated her case, saying it needs to go before a jury. (Photo Credit: ARLOU_ANDREI/Shutterstock.com)

Appeals Court Reinstates Nurse Anesthesiologist’s Disability Discrimination Case

Nurse anesthesiologist Paula E. Babb claims her employer, Maryville Anesthesiologists P.C., discriminated against her for having a disability — even though she does not. The sixth U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Cincinnati has reinstated her case after the U.S. District Court in Knoxville, Tennessee granted Maryville summary judgment in dismissing the case.

While Babb claims she was fired from her job in 2016 because her employers believed she had vision problems, Maryville claims she was fired because she committed two clinical errors that put patients at risk.

“Maryville Anesthesiologists wholeheartedly disagrees, and asserts it fired Babb, not because of any visual disability (whether real or not), but rather, because Babb committed two ‘clinical errors’ that placed her patients at grave risk of injury,” the ruling says.

However, Babb maintains in the case that she was fired because one of Maryville’s physician-owners witnessed her “place her face very close to a computer screen” and asked her why she was doing that. Babb said she had a “congenital retinal condition” that made it difficult for her to read screens and medical records, but that it did not affect her ability to do her job. The one physician-owner relayed the message to another and added Babb “would be blind in ten years,” according to court documents.

The document then goes on to say two more of Maryville’s physician-owners emailed Babb about her vision. They scheduled a meeting with her and told her to visit an opthamologist to confirm her vision was stable. After the meeting, the physician-owners had an email conversation where they acknowledged  they ‘all kn[e]w that’ an ophthalmologist couldn’t issue an opinion definitively ‘clearing’ Babb to practice anesthesiology (because ophthalmologists generally do not make those kinds of calls), Babb’s situation might require them to ‘talk to [their] attorney,'” according to the case.

In the following months, the case says, Babb was involved in a catch-22. Her bosses told her to ask other staff members in the hospital to help confirm she was reading monitors correctly, which made it seem more apparent she had eye problems. These concerns made their way into her annual evaluations.

But one of the physician-owners learned Babb had committed an error in Dec. 2015 unrelated to her eyesight, where she began waking a patient up too early before he had been moved to the proper bed, which caused him to nearly fall off of the operating table. Another error she made occurred in 2016, when a patient’s arm began twitching before a surgery, suggesting she did not sufficiently paralyze him.

In January 2016, physician-owners met to discuss Babb’s vision problems and these two errors. They voted to fire her. According to court documents, Maryville says it reached this decision solely because Babb’s “clinical errors” and not her vision. Babb says she had never received any complaints about her work or had these incidents brought to her attention before.

Furthermore, an email another nurse anesthesiologist sent to the others attributed Babb’s firing completely to her vision. The court document quotes the email:

As most of you know, [Babb] has been having major issues with her eyesight and as of late, it has seemed to be getting even worse. We have had numerous complaints from [hospital] staff regarding her inability to read the monitor, etc. Over the past several months the group has given her several opportunities to provide documentation from her eye specialist saying that she was safe to practice. [Babb] was unable to provide this documentation.This, in addition to a few other issues, has forced the group to make a very difficult decision. As of today, she is no longer with our group. Sorry to be the bearer of bad news. This was one of the reasons that our meeting was postponed. See you all tomorrow.

After her termination, Babb filed suit with the District Court charging violation of the Americans with Disabilities Act, which states an employer cannot fire someone for thinking they are disabled, even if they are not.

The Court of Appeals decision to reinstate the case says the trial must go before a jury. It says there is both a question of the reasonableness of the choice to fire Babb based on the two errors and the question of whether the decision to fire Babb was based solely on the errors, or if her perceived disability played a role.

Related Story: Washington State Supreme Court Determines Obesity Discrimination Unlawful

Latest News

Boeing Elects Lynne Doughtie to Board of Directors, Following Resignation of Director Caroline Kennedy

Originally published on boeing.mediaroom.com. The Boeing Company (No. 27 on The 2020 DiversityInc Top 50 Companies for Diversity list) board of directors today announced that Lynne Doughtie has been elected to the board, replacing Caroline Kennedy who has resigned following three years of dedicated service. Doughtie, 58, retired from KPMG in 2020, after serving as U.S. Chairman and…

NYPD under suit

NYPD Sued for Years of Racial Abuse and Use of Excessive Force; Trump Administration Approves Discrimination Against LGBTQ individuals; and More

NYPD sued by Attorney General for years of racial abuse and use of excessive force. In what’s been called a “landmark lawsuit,” The New York Times has reported that New York state Attorney General Letitia James is suing the city of New York, the mayor and the NYPD’s leaders, alleging…

NBCUniversal News Group Launches NBCU Academy, Offering Training to Universities and Community Colleges

NBCUniversal News Group launched NBCU Academy, a new, innovative, multiplatform journalism training and development program for four-year university and community college students through education, on-campus training and online programming. Originally published on corporate.comcast.com. The initiative includes a curated onsite curriculum for hands-on learning experience with world-class NBCU News Group journalists,…

Kaiser

Kaiser Permanente: Committing $8.15M for Racial Equity

Originally published on about.kaiserpermanente.org. Grants to grassroots and nonprofit organizations will help address structural racism and practices that prevent communities of color from achieving good health and well-being. Kaiser Permanente (DiversityInc Hall of Fame), the nation’s largest integrated, nonprofit health system, has awarded $8.15 million to support dozens of nonprofit…

Toyota Research Institute and Stanford University’s Dynamic Design Lab Study How to Improve Automotive Safety

Originally published on pressroom.toyota.com. Inspired by the Skills of Professional Drift Drivers, Research Seeks to Combine the Technology of Vehicle Automation with Artificial Intelligence Algorithms What if every driver who ran into trouble had the instinctive reflexes of a professional race car driver and the calculated foresight of a supercomputer…

Tribal elder

Loss of Tribal Elders Due to COVID-19 Decimating Indigenous Populations; Colorado Revamps Common-Law Marriage Requirements, Making Them More Friendly for LGBTQ Couples; and More

Loss of tribal elders due to COVID-19 decimating Indigenous populations. The Muscogee, Navajo, Blackfeet Nation, White Mountain Apache and Choctaw tribes are among the many communities of Indigenous people suffering irreparable losses due to the COVID-19 pandemic, New York Times reporter Jack Healy has reported. Already impacted by infection rates…