Subscribe to DiversityInc today!

Corporate Options
Newsletter Sign Up
Log In
DiversityInc Magazine | Advertise | Special Sections | Resource Guide | Foundation | Webinars | Benchmarking | DiversityInc Careers
Site Sponsors
Marriott
Home Depot
Bank of America
Cox Communications
Well Point
KPMG
Verizon
Aetna
Wachovia
PWC
Deloitte
ibm




You are here: DiversityInc | Readers' Comments | Is Tropic Thunder Of . . .
"Is 'Tropic Thunder' Offensive to Blacks, People With Mental Disabilities?" Readers' Comments



August 15, 2008

DiversityInc readers had a lot to say about "Is 'Tropic Thunder' Another Slap in the Face to Diversity?"

Here are their unedited comments.

Posted: Thursday, Sep 11, 2008
Is 'Tropic Thunder' Offensive to Blacks, People With Mental Disabilities?

people like me who have a disabilities didn't think it was funny. I got to see a mentally challenge person cry because they felt for the 1st time that they were different and something was wrong with it. My friends and I plan on taking action against this movie it should not be allowed to be sold at stores when it comes out on dvd. Ben Stiller just lost a whole mess of fans.

letisia comstock

Posted: Friday, Aug 29, 2008
Is 'Tropic Thunder' Offensive to Blacks, People With Mental Disabilities?

The tagline of the movie "Never go full retard" was what initially sparked off the protest surrounding this movie. It's my understanding that the words retard and retarded are used more than once. I won't go to see this movie, despite being a fan of Ben Stiller's other movies.

There are other ways of being funny without being offensive.

Karen Putz

Posted: Tuesday, Aug 26, 2008
Is 'Tropic Thunder' Offensive to Blacks, People With Mental Disabilities?

Funny, there's no mention of Downey's foil in the movie, who DOES act like a buffoon and plays the "real" black actor. The trouble is that contemporary racism works by leaving the door open. That's why we have young whites who think that dressing up like a Black 'pimp' and having a frat party about it is funny. (That, nooses, other Anti-black campus events and much worse- Jena was not an isolated incident last year. Look it up.) And Inside jokes- if that's what this movie is, and believe me, only people 'in the businesss' would ever think that-- are rarley deconstructed by the general population, especially a priviledged majority. And the parody/ satire is only hauled out in excuse for one's offensive actions. Brilliantly though, this time it was done in advance of the release.

Kayle Emma

Posted: Monday, Aug 18, 2008
Is 'Tropic Thunder' Offensive to Blacks, People With Mental Disabilities?

There's not one single thing funny about the Vietnam War and what our veterans went through. Not even a joke about a joke about a joke.

Guess I'm goin' soft...

And on the flip, if the audience has to work that hard for the punchline, then maybe the joke isn't funny?

God bless our troops, and God bless our Vietnam Vets.

Lindsay Blaz

Posted: Sunday, Aug 17, 2008
Is 'Tropic Thunder' Offensive to Blacks, People With Mental Disabilities?

Where's the beef? I think some people's sense of humor was shot off in the war. If we were completely politically correct we wouldn't ever mention gender, nationality or anything that makes a person individual. In other words, doing stories about people with disabilities could be perceived as voyeurism...Why are we examining these individuals? because they're different, but we're still staring.

Nan Bramley

 Next



Digg digg this | Mixx! mixx! | reddit | del.icio.us | Seed_NewsvineNewsvine | Google_Bookmark | Yahoo_Bookmark
 e-mail article | print print | post comments | NEWSLETTER

Send Your Comments About This Article Now

First Name:

Last Name:
Your E-Mail Address
Message Subject
Message:

Clicking "Send Message" registers your e-mail address to
receive DiversityInc's Free Daily Newsletter.


©DiversityInc. Reproduction in any format is absolutely prohibited.





Also Read
'Is Obama Victory for Blacks or for Everyone?' Readers' Comments
'Young, Black, Latino & White Voters Choose Obama' Readers' Comments
Satire? Tasteless? The New Yorker Slammed for Obama Terrorist Portrayal: Readers' Comments
Things 'to' Say to Black Coworkers: Readers' Comments
'Stop Calling Me Honey': Readers React to Things NEVER to Say

click here to ask a question | click here to read recent Q & A
Most Popular Articles on DiversityInc
Obama Wouldn't Be First Black President

Obama's Victory: Headlines From Around the Nation

On President's Day, Remember Your 5 Black Presidents

Is Obama Victory for Blacks or for Everyone?

DiversityInc Top 50 Dinner Announcement

Daily News Picks
Al-Qaeda Insults Obama With Racial Slur
Is 'Don't Ask, Don't Tell' History?
Black and Latino Kids Face Deadly Wait for Donor Hearts
Comedian Wanda Sykes Comes Out
More Popular Articles on DiversityInc
Young, Black, Latino & White Voters Choose Obama

Who Is Michelle Obama?

Do Blacks Need to Relax Their Natural Hair to Get Promoted?

The World Reacts to Obama's Victory

Oprah Is Boycotted After Refusing Palin Interview

Recruiting Top American Indian Talent: The Unique Blend

Hoaxes, Jokes & Other Election Blunders

In Some Ways, American Indians Are Losing Their Identity

Gay-Marriage Supporters Take Hits in 3 Key States

Why Whites Can't 'Get Over' Color

Election Day '08: Remember the Shoulders You Stand On

How to Get Talented Women to Stay

Come Election Day, Hurricane Victims, Foreclosure Victims May Be Left Out

Where Do Most Black Women Spend Their Money?

Veterans Day: Remember the Forgotten Soldiers

Is It OK to Speak Spanish in the Workplace?

Join Now! | Log In | Contact Us | Post Jobs | Magazine | Advertise | About Us | Privacy Policy | Site Map
Legal | Research & Reference | Financial Literacy | Video Network | Foundation | Webinars
Thanks for visiting
DiversityInc.com!
To continue viewing free articles on our site and in our newsletter, please enter your e-mail address in the box.
E-mail

Welcome to DiversityInc Careers
Join Now to Avoid Pop-Ups. Save 50%!
Choose a Premium Subscription Here.

FREE Memberships
We never reveal, share or sell member information. For complete details, see our Privacy Statement.