9 Things NEVER to Say to White Colleagues
Frank McCloskey's wife of 31 years,
Debbie, talked about her husband with her new coworkers, telling them about his
job as vice president of diversity for Georgia Power. During lunch one day,
Debbie, who is white, had just finished telling a story about Frank's diversity
efforts when a colleague of hers said, "I want to tell you how courageous it is
that you are married to an African American." Oops! Frank is white.
Too often, white men--and to a
lesser extent, white women--are assumed to have no role in
diversity-and-inclusion efforts. But white people who are heterosexual,
Christian and not disabled can and do champion diversity efforts. To assume
otherwise is like assuming that talented Black or Latino executives do not
exist. To further explore stereotypes about
white people in the corporate-diversity world, DiversityInc talked to several
white men intimately involved in diversity-and-inclusion efforts. Here are 10
things they suggest never saying to your white colleagues.
1. "You're a
carpet-bagger" or "Why is a white guy doing this?" It is
often said in murmurs but not openly talked about that white people involved in
the diversity industry are carpet-baggers, people involved for the money rather
than the mission. "A person at a financial institution
[who works in diversity] said I'm only making money from diversity. But if she
is working in a diversity department, isn't she making money off of diversity
also? Now that we got past the fact that we both make money on diversity, let's
look at what we do for diversity," says Visconti. In 2006, Visconti and DiversityInc
Partner and Cofounder "Foulis and I staked our whole lives
on this," says Visconti. "It's bigoted to say that I'm a carpet-bagger … It's
insulting and it's behavior that you wouldn't want perpetrated on
yourself." Peacock
adds, "When you hear,
'What's a white guy doing in this [diversity] space?'--which people have said
with a smile--their perception was that if you're doing this, aren't you taking
something away from people like yourself and giving it to someone else? And
that's not the point at all. "Diversity is not about promoting
one group over another group, and for too long, that's how it's been viewed,"
says Peacock. 2. "You're not
diverse" Diversity includes white people. It
is incorrect and insulting to use the word "diverse" to refer to people other
than white heterosexual men with no ADA-defined disabilities. All people are
included in the concept of "diversity." As a result, properly executed diversity
management benefits all people in an organization. Also,
too often, non-white people assume whites don't come from a diverse background
or have any experience with different cultures. Some white people also make this
mistake. But Peacock points out that while his skin might be "white," his
background is diverse, even more so than many people from traditionally
underrepresented groups. "I come from a family with two
different histories, from different sides of the world," says Peacock, who is
from Peacock adds that in today's
society, being exclusionary by any standard should not be tolerated. It is also
not the best method of building networks. "Anything that is exclusionary you
have to avoid," says Peacock. "The reason Sen. [Barack] Obama is so successful
is … because he's getting the white vote. Why is he getting this? Because for
the first time, someone is talking about how all of us will achieve this
American dream, and the important word is 'all' of us." Furthermore, Visconti makes the
point that in today's Moreover, Visconti affirms that to
assume a white person cannot have a true, heartfelt connection with diversity is
historically wrong. "Benjamin Franklin was the president
of the Anti-Slavery Society, William Lloyd Garrison founded the abolitionist
newspaper 'The Liberator' and was a mentor to Frederick Douglass, and Lyndon
Johnson had a profound change of mind and became an advocate of civil-rights and
anti-poverty legislations. Many white people have been and still are at the
forefront of societal change to eliminate oppression and increase equity," says
Visconti. 3. "There's no way you as a white
person can understand" But the knee-jerk response is "If
that's true, then why should I try to understand?" says Howard Ross, the white
founder and chief learning officer for Cook Ross, a Maryland-based diversity
consultancy. Don't beat up your white colleagues
by cloaking them in the shroud of "ignorant oppressor" while wearing the shroud
of "victim." Look for the personal stories that will develop commonalities and
shared ideas. "Now at some level that's true--I
can never be an African American, Latino or Asian American. But also, it
minimizes the various levels of discrimination that everyone deals with and can
understand through the human dynamics that apply to all people," says Ross.
Visconti adds that saying you can't
understand because you're white is treating a white person as if he or she is
ignorant of culture and diversity issues. "It belittles the good intentions
[white people] may have," says Visconti. "It doesn't progress the discussion.
Considering that nearly [one-quarter] of 4. White men are automatically "in
the corporate in-crowd" Being isolated or segregated from
the in-crowd is not unique to executives who are Black, Latino, Asian American,
Native American, people with disabilities or LGBT people. "For the most part, [white men]
don't feel they're included or privileged," says McCloskey. "Unfortunately, it's
too easy to put [that feeling] at the foot of race, diversity and gender
initiatives. Corporate McCloskey adds that corporate
leadership must rid itself of subtle behaviors that create disengagement and
mistrust, "not only for African Americans, women and other dimensions of
diversity but also for white men." 5. "You're just a typical white
person" Yes, Barack Obama said it and was
thoroughly chastised for describing his white grandmother as a "typical" white
person. The implication in such a statement is that all white people are alike,
and that white people are all predisposed to be prejudiced. But characterizing
anyone based on the presupposed behavior of a group is a slippery slope that
leads to confusion and miscommunication, says Ross. "Any language that sees white people
as a group, such as 'typical white men,' is as offensive to white folks as it is
to people of color," says Ross. "When branded 'typical white person,' it
diminishes them and creates a sense of hopelessness and that [they are] never
going to be anything other than a 'white person.'" "Don't assume I don't want to
learn," adds Visconti. 6. "You KNOW you're being
racist" In the absence of concrete evidence,
don't assume that a comment considered prejudiced was the result of a conscious
thought process designed to stereotype, says Ross. "We're learning that an overwhelming
number of decisions people make are not made by bad intentions but are made by
people blind to their own behavior," says Ross. "Rather than assume that a
person intended to be sexist or prejudiced, assume they didn't mean any
malicious intent." McCloskey adds that often people who
are not white assume whites know their behavior is racist or prejudiced: "But
being in a place of privilege is such a powerful place to be that the assumption
is that everyone is living my life experience." Ross says people should stop before
they reply to a comment deemed prejudicial and ask themselves if their reaction
is the result of thinking the white person is like "all white people" or is a
person who "happens to be white." "If I'm dealing with them as 'all white people,' my triggers will be [switched]," says Ross. "If I'm dealing with them as 'a person who happens to be white,' then they'll be [communicative]." 7. "You talk about us when we're not
around" Being in the majority group provides
freedom from the constant concern of race issues and fear of people who do not
share your racial or ethnic background. So white people usually are not talking
about Blacks, Latinos or Asian Americans when people from those groups are not
around. "Generally, we're being oblivious
and doing our thing," says Visconti. "Being oblivious doesn't make you a bad
person. It just makes you oblivious." 8. "You've got all the
money." "My first response is, 'No, I
don't,'" says Jeff Hitchcock, executive director for the Center for the Study of
White American Culture. He adds that while the majority of people who are poor
are white, it is true that the percentage of whites who are poor is less than
the percentage of Blacks, Latinos and Native Americans who are
poor. But such a comment uses broad
generalization to make a point. Generalizations rarely are the best way to open
up the lines of communication on a one-on-one basis. Hitchcock also says that many people
mistake the make-up and the purpose of his organization, assuming that any
reference to white culture must be a veiled reference to white supremacy. To
dispel that notion, he put the following in bold letters on the center's
homepage: "Not an organization for
white supremacists as some people might infer, we are instead a multiracial
organization that looks at whiteness and white American
culture." 9. "I don't like white people" or "I
don't get white people" Unfortunately, people do communicate
things like this. "In a business setting, a person probably wouldn't respond,
but people can give off vibes," says Hitchcock. "Sometimes I get that vibe from
people of color and I don't know if it's me giving off a vibe or it's them--it's
probably both." Hitchcock contends that it's tough
not to acknowledge that anger when considering a history that included slavery,
segregation and systemic racism. Such a national culture forced Black people,
Asian Americans and Latinos into subservient roles. But, he says, assume the
best rather than assuming the worst when interacting with people.
"As a white person, you should be
aware of that history and how that has led us to the present," adds
Hitchcock. "What gets me in trouble is thinking that my truth is the truth--holding onto some idea I need to let go of and I'm holding on to it because I'm comfortable," says McCloskey. "You're saying, 'You adapt to me.' I'm saying leadership in the past has been rewarded for forcing others to adapt. It's time for leadership to expand its ability to adapt to others who are different." |