Disgraceful or Absolutely Right? Readers Respond to Ferraro's Obama Bashing
Compiled by the DiversityInc staff. Date Posted: March 13, 2008
"Desperate," "divisive" and "disgraceful" are just a few of the words DiversityInc readers have used to describe Geraldine Ferraro's stunning comments regarding Sen. Barack Obama. Ferraro, who was a member of Sen. Hillary Clinton's finance committee until the firestorm over these comments forced her to resign last night, said if Obama "was a white man, he would not be in this position … he happens to be very lucky to be who he is."
After initially offering only a lukewarm denouncement of the comments, Clinton finally rejected Ferraro and the statement yesterday at a forum sponsored by the National Newspaper Publishers Association, a group of more than 200 Black community newspapers across the nation, reports The Associated Press.
Our readers have been passionately responding to our question about this issue. Although most of our readers vehemently disagree with Ferraro, others said she was "right on the mark" and "absolutely right."
What do you think about Ferraro's comments? Tell us what you think.
Here are many of the unedited responses DiversityInc has received.
You ask any African-American whether or not they're "lucky" to be an African-American and I will show you a bald-face liar. I'm proud to be African-American, but how many jobs have I lost; how many apartments I couldn't rent, even though I could afford to pay; how many cabs I couldn't catch in NYC, or schools I couldn't get into because of my race? Ms. Ferraro will NEVER know what that feels like, and her comments about Barack Obama demonstrate she has no clue about all the hell African-Americans have caught since they offloaded my ancestors on the docks of Jamestown, Virginia. Why? Because she has the complexion for the protection. Her being a white female protects her. She's also inherently racist; she said similar comments about Jesse Jackson 20 years ago. Hillary Clinton told her to step down and make it look like she's voluntarily doing so because she doesn't want the "racist" label added to "scorched-earth", "monster" or any other label she's picked up since she started this.
Until she decided to inject race into the campaign, and play on the fear of race, Ms. Clinton ran a respectable campaign. Now it's junk and further convinces me that while America is ready for a woman to be President, that woman should NOT be Hillary Clinton.
--Leutisha Stills
I thought the remarks were stupid and uninformed. Several friends have tried to defend Ferraro by saying she was misinterpreted. To that I say that instead of trying to further clarify the remark, she got all uppity and actually suggested the Obama campiagn apologize to her. Her comment was not nearly as troubling as her irritating defense of it.
--Lamonte John
The media is constantly dividing the polls between black-white male-female. This whole election is becoming based on what the person is and not what they can do for the people. I personally never heard anything about Obama until he started his campaign. I think Geraldine is 100% correct that he is lucky to be where he is considering the low profile that he has had nationally. The country has to stop turning everything into a racial comment and concentrate on the real problems of the country.
--Dean Wight
Geraldine Ferraro represents the same type of old-world thinking that is generationally out of touch with America. The experience issue that everyone raises is important since it makes sense that in fairness to all running, a sensible question can and should be asked on how they would deal confrontationally to national security threats and the economy. This comment didn't represent what his lack of experience was; it represented her lack of awareness of how America has socially shifted to provide experience to those individuals that have successfully applied their knowledge to create other successes in their career.
Barack Obama's impressive personality not only exceeds intelligence in the areas of creative thinking/strategic ability to employ the expertise of others who have experience that exceeds his in areas where we need new and innovative thinking, his campaign strategy has out fundraised Mrs. Clinton's campaign..which is what Geraldine Ferraro's job is. Suffice it to say if we're giving credit to individuals here, he's done a much better job than she has done.
--Carol Wyatt
Ferraro is correct. All a Black person has to do is run for president and s/he becomes a shoo-in: reference Presidents (Shirley) Chisholm, (Jesse) Jackson and (Al) Sharpton. Since half the American voters are Black and only 15% are women, women have a much harder time getting elected! To quote Bill Clinton "Give me a break!"
P.S. most of the pundits also missed the significance of Tuesday's primaries. The big story is not that Obama won Mississippi; the story is that Obama won TEXAS and Clinton did not.
--John Odom
I think that it's possible that it is true that being black is an advantage for Obama. Why not? It's a good thing. It's possible that being a woman is Hillary's advantage. We just don't know for certain how it plays out when it comes to voting. It's also possible that Ferraro's comments were racially motivated. We just don't know. If she has a history that supports the idea that she is racist, then it's probable. If there's no history that supports the accusation that she is racist, then we have to assume it's equally possible that it was a comment made that was not racially motivated.
--Aubrey Morgan
I was, quite frankly, appalled. Is Geraldine Ferraro in the position she is in just because she is a woman? Is Hilary Clinton in her position just because she is a woman? Ferraro's comment is just more of what we have heard so often for years and years. If people of color don't "make it" it is their fault for not trying hard enough. If people of color do "make it" it is because they are being babied, coddled, given special opportunities because of their skin color, etc. In fact, reams and reams of research on implicit bias, etc. clearly show that darker skin color is still very much a handicap in this society and that people of color have to work much harder to prove they are qualified. It is appalling that Ferraro didn't even realize her comments were racist and that initially Clinton hardly raised an eyebrow. I sincerely hope this incident highlights some of the differences between Clinton and Obama.
--Dawn Hunt
Ferraro was right to step down. Once again, some so-called feminists want to express a feeling of entitlement to the White House based on their gender and see Barack as an undeserving obstacle. The idea that because Obama is a black man, he is receiving preferential treatment over Senator Clinton, who is a woman, is absolutely absurd. Obama has excellent credentials, including serving on the Harvard Law Review. He worked in the community, did not work for Wal-Mart, and served in both the state and the federal legislatures. Hillary is a lawyer, but also served as First Lady. Serving tea to heads of state does not qualify you to be a foreign policy expert and her only job in the Clinton Admin., health care, was a miserable failure. Yes, Obama is interesting, but if he were using the same divisive tactics as Gerry and Hillary, we would not be interested in him. Yes, the black community is proud of him. Let's consider the historic nature of this campaign. Not since slavery has there been an African American who has come so close to the White House. Millions of women voted for Hillary because of her gender. Is anyone complaining about that?
I remember when Mrs. Ferraro did little to include black women when she ran for Vice President. For that reason, we formed the National Political Congress of Black Women, to support ourselves, knowing we would get little support from her and her colleagues. Her recent comments remind me of that unfortunate turn of events. Hilary has lost all credibility not distancing herself from Ferraro's race-baiting, conscious or unconscious.
--SJ Wilcher
It is very sad that we are in the year 2008 and the same comments that have been used against successful and qualified people of color are facing Senator Obama. When African Americans get promoted or selected for positions, racists frequently say they got them because they are Black and not because they are qualified. Their is frequently no regard for their achievements. Its time to end this form of racism and see this campaign for what it is--a formidable one with two formidable, qualified candidates. I do have one question for Ms. Ferraro, how does she explain Senator Obama's appeal in the predominantly White states such as Iowa, Alaska, Connecticut, Idaho, Minnesota, Missouri, North Dakota, Utah, Nebraska, Maine, Wisconsin, Vermont, and Wyoming?
--LaJuana Caldwell
I glad that Geraldine Ferraro was made to step down. The number of people who run for public office while secretly holding very racist views is frightening to me as an African American. Until all people are treated as equals and allowed to share in the American dream, America will never be the great country that it should be.
--Kathy Forsythe
Ferraro is right. He is NOT Qualified to run an entire country... yet. Maybe next election. He is a professional speaker. So he talks well, but does NOT say that much. I am actually sick of hearing, "Change" come out of his mouth, like so many others. I think the "Change," he is really talking about is being the first Black President. Obama has never said what he is really going to do. I don't care what color or sex a person is. I want an EXPERIENCED FAIR President, that is NOT AFRAID to stand up & fight for this nation. I do NOT like all their marketing sexist digs..."If Obamam was a woman" per say. Then "Change" might mean....menopause. Gee his speeches would be phrased differently. All in all, Obama is starting to sound like a broken record. If he is hurt being called a baby, then tell him get over it. A tough guy wouldn't let names bother him. I agree with Ferraro.
--Kimberly Panfil
To say that I am not surprised would be an understatment. I have seen in the past several months with disappointing results at the negativity concerning race that has been used in the Clinton campaign in order to elicit support within the black community. I was one of those Clinton supporters but lately I have seen a side to both of the Clintons that I believe I chose not to see early on. I believe that Barack Obama is capable of weathering this storm and that he is just the leader we need. A new face in the White House. He may not have the experience that everyone believes that he should have but he has new and fresh ideas and can lead this country to the future not spiraling down in the past.
--Shawna Banks
I think Ferraro, like many other white individuals in America has convinced themselves that they are not racist; does not even realize how truly sterotypical their thinking is. Obama has truly forced many whites to face themselves including Bill and Hilary. Bill said every thing except the Nword. No one could have invisioned the impact he would have on Americans, especially the generation that does not see the racial lines as definitive as my generation' (I am 63). and all I want is more of my money in my pockets, and our babies to stop dying in a war that we should have never began. A war that was began based on a bunch of lies that generated fear in the minds of certain Americans. Obama is everything the we as Blacks have been told for four hundred years that we are not. He is Black, confident, educated, a fantastic speaker, he does not see race as many do. He has a vision for the country not just the Trumps of the world. Ferraro is an under cover racist and her words reflected her true opinion of the Black man that had the audacity to think he could run against white; be it male or female for the highest office in the nation and win.
--Betty Blue
What an ignorant, unacceptable comment to make. All she did is unify Obama supporters. For those who perhaps were fence sitting, her remark will probably have some become Obama supporters as they recognize that racist thinking still exists. Maybe she finally showed her true colors? I honestly believe that the majority of Obama supporters support him because he is a uniter, an includer...just the opposite of the intention of Ferraro's remark.
--Karen Green
America's shadow rears its head at last through the thoughtless utterances of quite a few on the campaign trail We are privileged to see what we have not been facing or what still exists under covers (or does it really). At some point, compassion, real compassion and not the hoax presented by the Bush administration, is in order as we struggle to find the maturity and humanity to embrace the disenfranchised.
Certainly, it is the talk of many my friends here in Europe, who, by the way, in addition to detesting Americans, are having a good laugh.
--Winfred Davis
Ms. Ferraro claims that her remarks have been taken out of context and exploited by the Obama campaign. I disagree. Ms. Ferraro is a sophisticated woman who understands that words have meaning. What she put out there had to be intentional and she should be prepared to address the concerns raised about her inflamatory words. It is highly untrue and unfair to say that Senator Obama would not be where he is if he were white. He is where he is because of who his is as a person. He is more than a black man. He is a hard working person who loves his family and his country. It is really unfortunate that some want to limit the discussion of our nation's important issues by focusing on something as unimportant as race. Ms. Ferraro ought to rethink her words and the Clinton campaign ought to distance itself from these divisive tactics. I for one am sick to death of the same old divide and conquer politics. Ms. Ferraro asks all to wake up and realize that this is the way it always was and will be. I personally have hope that it can be what we want it to be - something different.
--C L
More Readers' Comments >>
 © DiversityInc 2008 ® All rights reserved. No article on this site can be reproduced by any means, print, electronic or any other, without prior written permission of the publisher.
|