|
Who Got a Perfect Score for GLBT Employees? Who's Still at the Bottom of the List?
By Angela D. Johnson
August 11, 2006
This article originally appeared on DiversityInc.com on August 26,
2004
The number of companies getting a perfect score for reaching out to for gay,
lesbian, bisexual and transgender (GLBT) employees and consumers has nearly
doubled in the past year, according to a study by a gay-rights organization.
Twenty-one major U.S. corporations earned a 100 percent rating in the
Washington, D.C.-based Human Rights Campaign (HRC)'s Corporate Equality Index,
which is in its second year. In 2001, 11 companies earned a perfect score.
The following companies scored 100 percent this year for the second time in a
row: Aetna, American Airlines, Apple Computer, Avaya, Eastman Kodak, Intel,
JPMorgan Chase, Lucent Technologies, NCR, Nike and Xerox. For Bank One, Capital
One Financial, Hewlett-Packard, IBM, Lehman Brothers, Levi Strauss, MetLife,
PG&E, Prudential Financial and S.C. Johnson & Son this year marks the
first time they've received perfect scores.
Two-hundred and fifty companies from either the Fortune 500 or Forbes 200
list of privately held businesses were judged on the following seven factors:
- Having a written non-discrimination policy covering sexual orientation in
their employee handbook or manual.
- Having a written non-discrimination policy covering gender identity and/or
expression in their employee handbook or manual.
- Offering health-insurance coverage to employee's same-sex domestic partners.
- Officially recognizing a GLBT employee-resource group, willingness to
support the formation of the GLBT employee-resource group or having a firm-wide
diversity council or working group whose mission specifically includes GLBT
diversity.
- Offering diversity training that includes sexual orientation and/or gender
identity and expression in the workplace.
- Engaging in respectful and appropriate marketing to the GLBT community
and/or private support through their corporate foundation or otherwise to GLBT
or HIV/AIDS-related organizations or events.
*Engaging in corporate action
that would undermine the goal of equal rights for lesbian, gay, bisexual or
transgender people.
"What we see this year is improvement in every category measured, from
written non-discrimination policies to domestic-partner health insurance
benefits and beyond," said Kim Mills, HRC education director. "Corporate America
continues to be a leader in the quest for GLBT civil rights."
Eight of the 10 new companies that scored 100 percent did so by adding gender
identity and/or expression to their equal employment opportunities policy. While
no company scored 0 percent, Aramark, Domino's, ExxonMobil, Meijer and National
Gypsum scored the index's lowest score of 14 percent.
ExxonMobil was the only company to overtly resist equal treatment for GLBT
employees, consumer and investors by continuing to oppose a shareholder
resolution asking the company to add sexual orientation to its equal employment
opportunity statement. Lockheed Martin, the most-improved company in the survey,
raised its score from 0 percent in 2002 to 71 percent in 2003 by adding sexual
orientation to its non-discrimination policy and offering domestic-partner
benefits.
Lockheed was one of 80 companies -- about one-third of the total -- to boost
their scores from the previous year. Meghan Mariman, a spokesperson for Lockheed
Martin, told DiversityInc that the company's performance on HRC's 2002 Corporate
Equality Index was not the catalyst for its change in GLBT policy.
Mariman said the company installed a diversity council in 2001 in order to
include an all-inclusive work environment. She said updating of the company's
non-discrimination policy and the addition of domestic partner benefits were
extensions of that effort.
Cracker Barrel, a company that has faced several lawsuits regarding racial
bias, has made some small gains in the GLBT community. Like Lockheed Martin, the
company scored 0 percent in 2002. This year, the company upped its score to 29
percent by withdrawing its opposition to a shareholder policy asking the company
to include sexual orientation in its non-discrimination policy and then adopting
such a policy.
The inclusion of sexual orientation in non-discrimination policies is the
most common criterion among the companies surveyed. Nearly all of the companies
surveyed, 238, or 95 percent, had such a policy, up from 93 percent last year.
Approximately three-quarters, 184, offered diversity training. This is 19
percentage points higher than last year's survey. In this year's survey,
diversity training replaced domestic-partner health insurance benefits as the
second most common criterion.
"The bottom line," said Mills, "is that successful businesses are
increasingly recognizing that equality works."
Send Your Comments About This Article Now
©DiversityInc. Reproduction in any format is absolutely prohibited.
|