White Cop Faces Racism in Police Department After Discovering Black Ancestry

Lawsuit raises questions on the validity of DNA testing, who qualifies as a victim of discrimination and the social construct of race.

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT WESTERN DISTRICT OF MICHIGAN

The findings of an AncestryDNA test have resulted in a lawsuit from a police sergeant in Hastings, Mich.

Police Sgt. Cleon Brown, who has been with the department for 19 years, discovered last fall that he is 18 percent African American, despite his long-held belief that he is part Native American. According to Brown’s lawsuit, racial taunts began right after his discovery.

The lawsuit, which names several officers and the City of Hastings as defendants, alleges that Police Chief Jeff Pratt referred to Brown as “Kunta.” Kunta Kinte is the main character in “Roots: The Saga of an American Family” by Alex Haley. The character was also featured in the television miniseries called “Roots.”

Brown, also an Army veteran, alleges in the lawsuit that “some police department employees started whispering ‘Black Lives Matter’ while pumping their fists as they walked past [Brown].”

Former Hastings Mayor Frank Campbell, who retired in January 2017, also allegedly took part in the racist behavior. According to the filing Campbell encountered Brown and “proceeded to tell a racist joke using the word ‘Negroid’ at least two or three times.” (Campbell is not named as a plaintiff.)

In December, a tan Santa figurine appeared in Brown’s stocking on a department Christmas tree. “18%” was written on its beard. The lawsuit claims the figurine was put there by Police Patrol Sgt. Kris Miller.

“After Plaintiff complained about the figurine, Defendant Miller used the phrase ‘Native American’ while talking to another officer,” the lawsuit states. “Plaintiff was walking byand heard what Defendant Miller said. Defendant Miller saw Plaintiff and said in asarcastic tone: ‘I better be careful, I don’t want to offend anyone.’”

Brown eventually filed a complaint with the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC). But the negative behavior reportedly only got worse. Members of the department removed Brown from their Facebook pages and did not let him play in two annual department basketball games.

Brown was also allegedly asked by Pratt, the chief, to resign from his position as sergeant.

According to the suit, the environment created by Brown’s fellow department members could jeopardize his safety on the job:

“Based on the openly hostile, retaliatory behaviors displayed by the Defendants (the City Manager, Police Chief, the Deputy Chief, one of four Sergeants, and one of seven Officers), and tacit approval of Defendants’ conduct by many other Hastings officers, it is more likely than not, Plaintiff will not have adequate back up in the event of an emergency. He could be seriously hurt.”

The city released a statement denying the allegations and claiming that Brown in fact initiated many of the jokes. According to the statement, Brown shared his DNA test results “in a very joking and jovial manner.”

The others Hastings officers largely disregarded the news until Brown (referred to as “Claimant” in the city’s release) would opt to bring it up:

“Claimant joked about the other results of the test and there was some discussion about the accuracy of the test results. Claimant initiated this conversation and the joking and banter that followed. The topic of Brown’s heritage was basically forgotten by the members of the Department until Brown would bring it up again so as to joke about it and do some mutual bantering with other officers about their heritage.”

“In fact,” the city claims, “Sgt. Brown joked about it in racially derogatory ways such as suggesting [that] he now knows why he ‘likes chicken so much,’ ‘the 18% is all in my pants,’ as well as other similarly inappropriate and derogatory comments and stereotypes.”

The statement also questions the validity of AncestryDNA’s results and whether Brown can even be considered a member of a protected class under anti-discrimination laws.

“The City of Hastings has never considered Sgt. Brown to be African-American,” the city notes. “More importantly, neither has Sgt. Brown.”

Brown denied the city’s allegations that he initiated the racist jokes.

While Brown was not previously “considered” Black, this perception seemed to change rather quickly, as Brown claims the taunts began not long after he shared his news.

And the American Sociological Association (ASA) in a statement about race, perceptions of race and race’s impact on society said that even if race is not biologically relevant in the way researchers used to believe, it is not a construct that can be ignored:

“As the leading voice for 13,000 academic and practicing sociologists, the ASA takes the position that calls to end the collection of data using racial categories are ill advised, although racial categories do not necessarily reflect biological or genetic categories. The failure to gather data on this socially significant category would preserve the status quo and hamper progress toward understanding and addressing inequalities in primary social institutions.”

To ignore the concept of race in Brown’s case, as Hastings’ statement suggests, is in fact more detrimental to society, the ASA reports:

“Although race is a social construct (in other words, a social invention that changes as political, economic, and historical contexts change), it has real consequences across a wide range of social and economic institutions. Those who favor ignoring race as an explicit administrative matter, in the hope that it will cease to exist as a social concept, ignore the weight of a vast body of sociological research that shows that racial hierarchies are embedded in the routine practices of social groups and institutions.”

AncestryDNA on its websites asserts a high confidence rating in its results and states, “DNA samples are tested in a secure third-party testing lab in the United States.”

“AncestryDNA uses advanced scientific techniques to produce your results. We measure and analyze a person’s entire genome at over 700,000 locations,” AncestryDNA states. “During the testing process, each DNA sample is held to a quality standard of at least a 98% call rate. Any results that don’t meet that standard may require a new DNA sample to be collected.”

An Inside Edition investigative piece in February tested AncestryDNA against other similar services, 23andMe and Family Tree DNA. Three sets of identical twins tested their DNA with a different provider. The two sets of triplets that enlisted 23andMe and Family Tree DNA found several differences among their results. But AncestryDNA, in this case, proved to be the most accurate:

“Not everyone was disappointed by the results. The Ancestry DNA test results for the New Jersey triplets were almost identical. It revealed that their roots are largely from Great Britain, 45%-47% and their Italian and Greek ancestry was exact at 25%.”

Paul Woodbury, an independent genetic genealogist, told Brigham Young University’s The Daily Universe, “AncestryDNA, like all other genetic genealogy testing options, has its pros and cons.”

According to the publication, “Woodbury cited a few issues that could arise with AncestryDNA, such as its reliance on the family history work of others. Since the information on many family trees is incompletely researched, users of AncestryDNA should be cautious to not accept the information too readily.”

But it is also “making great strides” in research of genealogic information, Woodbury added.

According to The New York Times, “this experience has given [Brown] a new appreciation for the effects of racism.”

“I just never thought it would be in Hastings, saying, like, racist comments to me,” he said. “All the years I’ve been there we never joked about race.”

He also told the publication that he has started questioning if his father always knew about his heritage.

“I’ve talked with a lot of family members and we feel, I don’t know this for a fact, we feel because he was born in 1940, he didn’t want anybody to know that he had Black heritage in him,” he said. “So I think he just came up with the Blackfoot Indian thing just to kind of sell it to people and hope that they’d believe it.

Read more news @ DiversityInc.com

Recommended Articles

18 comments


  • I attended an auditorium meeting at University City Missouri High School several years ago. The topic was on curriculum. One student was recognised and he said he wanted to learn about both sides of his heritage. European and African.

    • PIANKI–This student, like all Americans, has MULTIPLE SIDES OF INHERITANCE,
      as do all human beings. Many African-Americans, like many Euro-Americans,
      share Native American and Asian genetic clusters. But all humans are essentially
      descendants of Africans, so all humans are “variations on a theme.”

  • Unfortunately, This man gets to have a little taste of what we have been experiencing for many years. And if he started it out by joking about it, he should accept the stupidity that he started. If I tell a racial joke with my white friends, I expect them to give it back to me a little bit. But it should be in fun and not to harm. He had better get some thicker skin and come to realize where our society is. It will get worse with the current trends before it gets better.

    HAMSTRONG

  • Charity Dell

    Genetic testing companies offer different products and different results, depending upon:

    1. Which genetic material is tested;
    2. What information is sought through testing.

    Sgt. Brown should get his ethnographic testing done by other companies,
    to get a better ethnographic picture of his patrilineal and matrilineal
    descent. Some genetic testing companies have larger databases
    of Native American groups. Many Native Americans are also
    of African descent, through the ancient African populations
    who lived in the Americas centuries before the Trans-Atlantic
    Slave Trade.

    Depending upon the testing nomenclature, “Native American” may
    be listed as:

    A. Asian.
    B. AmerIndian.
    C. Mestizo.
    D. Native American.

    3. Y-DNA testing will give the the most ancient DNA data on the paternal line,
    the most ancient data linked to the father’s Y chromosome.

    4. Mitochondrial testing will supply the most ancient DNA data on the maternal line,
    the date linked directly to the mother’s X chromosome.

    5. Autosomal testing will supply both ancient and modern (last 500 years) ancestral
    lines through both sets of chromosomes (23 paternal; 23 maternal). This does not
    yield “percentages”, but does show genetic clusters that match both native and
    diaspora population matches.

    6. Autosomal testing will also reveal the HAPLOGROUP–the place on the
    Human Genome Tree your mother and/or father is placed.

    Sgt. Brown could get more accurate ethnic data by testing with companies
    that supply native population matches, such as:

    7. http://www.DNATribes.com.
    8. http://www.dnaancestry.com (also called Genebase). They provide more extensive
    genetic information, and the haplogroup; they also provide matches to people with similar profiles.

    Sgt. Brown’s Native American ancestry may show up in DNATribes or
    through Genebase–both of these testing services have more genetic data than Ancestry.com.

    9. AfricanAncestry will test only the Y-DNA and Mitochondrial lines.
    10. FamilyTreeDNA will reveal the Haplogroup and matches to other
    people who have tested.

    If all those other police folks had their DNA tested, they might all be in
    for some shocking surprises! Many “white” southern folks have both
    Northern and Sub-Saharan African DNA in their little genes and
    chromosomes…and the DNA molecule ALWAYS tells the truth!

    • Native American can also show up as Middle Eastern on DNA tests. My “Cherokee” shows up as Middle Eastern (non-Arab). Other than, I am mostly Celtic.

      • Charity Dell

        SOAPBOX0916–Many Cherokees ARE of Middle Eastern descent. There are many articles
        available about this genetic heritage. As Hebrew peoples migrated to all the continents,
        it is not surprising this shows up. It also showed up in my mother’s line, as we are African-American
        descendants of African Hebrews on both the paternal and maternal lines.

        Your “Celtic” probably includes many Scandinavian lines, Iberian lines, Asian and North African heritage.
        Have you tested with any genetic testing companies?

  • Yeah, it sounds different when you are on the other side of the humor, right?

  • Something is clearly wrong with the organization if this is an issue. Half of all supposed whites in 1970 who could trace one side of their family back to before the Civil War were at least 1/16 black. And that was by genealogy, not genetic testing (which would produce an even higher number). As part of any settlement, all the tormenters should be forced to submit to genetic testing and publicize their results….

    • STEVE–I like your “punishment!” I am sure the Boys In Blue would go into
      collective SHOCK if they got their DNA results. What most people do not
      understand is that the DNA molecule tells the TRUTH, the WHOLE TRUTH
      and “NOTHING BUT THE TRUTH” about our origins on both sides of our
      families, going all the way back to antiquity! :-)

      And YES, the tormenters should have their results published publicly
      and posted in the precinct. I’ll bet a bunch of them will STILL defy
      the truth and DENY their genetic origins; because most racists have
      falsely based their identities upon what they think/believe they are
      not. Then when they hear the TRUTH, they are VERY RATTLED, because
      they do not understand that their sociocultural identity is not the same
      as their TRUE GENETIC ORIGINS.

  • If his workplace environment is as backward as he portrays, the results would probably be the same if he were 18% Native American.

  • It is very likely that some of those “who got jokes” would find some negroid in their DNA if they chose to test it. But doesn’t this also say something about our police departments and some of the hidden feelings they have about race? They get insulted when it’s suggested that their behavior towards people of color is as much about their racist feelings as it is about feeling threatened. Officer Brown may now understand a little bit better what the other side goes through when dealing with his breathen.

    • So let me get this straight, his DNA is 18% African American is this is the response he gets? OMG what a sad world this is, so much hate

  • Officer Brown made the mistake of “boasting” about his discovery. This implied that he was taking the black “side.” Whiteness has always been a combination of phenotype AND behavior. Far worse than anything those policemen have done is the fact that black and black-identified elites promote a “one drop” myth to try and force mulattoes and mixed whites into their “race,” kicking and screaming. Meanwhile, there is a gentleman’s agreement in society that the black ancestry in Hispanics and Arabs will be politely ignored.

    http://multiracial.com/index.php/2004/09/01/white-racial-identity-racial-mixture-and-the-one-drop-rule/

    • Black people did not make this rule so we are not forcing anyone. Be who you want to be. When I see dark people I see black. If they say they are Indian, Hispanic, European, whatever, I accept and move on. We can’t force anybody to be black.

  • Very common for white men to think there native American but natives where killed raped and tortured there was no Disney fairy tale …but to have African genes makes alot more sense having slaves made it alot easier to mix blood lines

  • Funny, it’s only a problem if ancestry has African in it. All other races are acceptable and pose no problem.

« Previous Article     Next Article »