Ask the White Guy: Can a White Man Speak With Authority on Diversity?
Question:
Upon returning to my office, re-energized by the DiversityInc event, I shared the information you addressed during your talk [when you] spoke about DiversityInc and mentioned your Ask the White Guy feature. When mentioning your feature to a group of white female colleagues, one responded by saying, what does he (a white guy) have to do with diversity; how does he create something like DiversityInc and how could he possibly speak with authority about diversity?
Answer:
I created DiversityInc as a consequence of having my consciousness raised by a friend, Tony Cato—at the time, a fellow Naval Aviator. He helped me start the thought process that led me to where I am today. He didn’t have an agenda; we were simply swapping stories as we worked together, a consequence of his volunteering to help me when I was assigned to be the Minority Officer Recruiter in Naval Recruiting District New Jersey. Tony is not a go-along-to-get-along guy; he’s tough, disciplined and very smart. He told me stories of being denied fair treatment because he’s Black. It took me awhile to understand how profound those stories are, but it did sink in eventually. I learned to share his indignation at poor treatment meted out as a result of discrimination—and the damage it does to our country.
White men are a part of diversity and there is a great deal of diversity among white men. [Read how corporations are showing white men what's in it for them: Do White Men Really Need Diversity Outreach?] I recently spoke to a group of 900 police and fire chiefs in Oregon—97 percent white men. I made the point that they might not think they have diversity as they sit around the fire house or police station and see nothing but white men—but some of those white men grew up in single-parent households, some grew up in large families, some went to college on athletic scholarships, some worked their way through—and some didn’t go at all. Some have a gay brother, some are gay themselves (and perhaps closeted). I told the chiefs that they could utilize the diversity they already have to gain new perspective on problems and in doing so would better fulfill their missions: to save lives. My point is that it is not skin color, gender or orientation that makes one “good at” managing diversity but mindset.
This mindset for majority-culture people requires an epiphany or an evolution in thinking that brings one to understand the extent of the discrimination around all of us that is perpetrated mostly by the majority culture.
Anyone can become “authoritative” about diversity. Nobody comes to the table that way. How you get there, in my opinion, starts with understanding history. I’ve gained a lot of perspective by reading books like Beverly Tatum’s “Why Are All the Black Kids Sitting Together in the Cafeteria,” Iris Chang’s “The Chinese in America,” Isabel Wilkerson‘s “The Warmth of Other Suns,” Douglas Blackmon’s “Slavery By Another Name,” Ira Katznelson’s “When Affirmative Action Was White” and Taylor Branch’s trilogy on the civil-rights era.
Watch Wells Fargo CEO John Stumpf discuss his personal commitment to diversity and how he holds his leaders accountable for diversity goals.
History is important, but what I’ve found transformative is personal involvement in organizations that do not serve you directly (by “you,” I mean loosely you as defined by gender, race, orientation, etc.). For example, I’m a trustee of Bennett College for Women, a historically Black college, and on the foundation board of New Jersey City University, a Hispanic-serving institution. At Rutgers University (where I am also a trustee), I co-chair the fundraising committee for Rutgers Future Scholars. We have raised $2 million in the past three years. I donate all of my speaking fees through the DiversityInc Foundation, which has distributed more than $500,000 since 2006. The life experience I’ve gained by serving these institutions has been invaluable.
Any executive can take the same steps to broaden their experience and cultural competence. We see how people work so hard to complete advanced degrees—and they are important—but life experience is how an executive does not become a Hosni Mubarak as our country and world change dramatically. This change is not just visual; it is about the rising power of liberated people to destroy the concept of “melting pot” as they gain the economic ability to command respect—as they are.
Watch Procter & Gamble CEO Bob McDonald discuss how the company’s commitment to community outreach helps improve its employees’ cultural competence.
I will note that people who are not in the majority culture must deal with the majority culture as they try to retain their own identity, but those in the majority culture do not really have to deal with anything BUT the majority culture (doesn’t make it right, but this is the reality). In this country, the majority culture is defined as white, male, heterosexual, Christian and not having an ADA-defined disability. But just because a person in the majority culture starts out with a much wider “blind spot” than people not in the majority culture doesn’t mean it’s impossible for white men to become open advocates for diversity and inclusion. It also doesn’t mean that a Black woman (for example) comes with an automatic Ph.D. in diversity management (it’s just a lot easier for the Black woman to see the problem in the first place). We must all come to the realization that, as a reader put it nicely, “I am not different than you, I am different like you.”
Luke Visconti’s Ask the White Guy column is a top draw on DiversityInc.com. Visconti, the founder and CEO of DiversityInc, is a nationally recognized leader in diversity management. In his popular column, readers who ask Visconti tough questions about race/culture, religion, gender, sexual orientation, disability and age can expect smart, direct and disarmingly frank answers.








10:17 am
Can a White man tell a Black man not to hate? Can a White man tell a Black man that he needs to get a job? Can a White man tell a Black man that he can be successful? Can a White man tell a Black man that he needs to take care of his family? Let’s not confuse the issue between telling a ‘person what is right, and telling him to do wrong.’ Of course a White person (man) can speak with authority on diversity. In
America who is better to fix the mess that the White Europeans have created. It is the White man! The Blacks can only appeal to the White man. The White man has the power to make a difference. “Mr. Gorbachev, tear down this wall.” (President Ronald Reagan).
The problem many have is that they don’t define truth as an absolute. Saying a White man can’t understand how it feels to be discriminated against is like saying, a White man can never speak the truth. It’s like saying, Franklin, you can’t put a splint on that person’s leg, because you’ve never had a broken leg. The truth is that the person has a broken leg and I know that the splint will help a person with a broken leg. Truth is the key here, not whether I have had a broken leg. The American Indians were lied to so many times by the White man, and when one told the truth they didn’t believe them until he put his life on the line. In the diversity issue, if truth is to be perceived for what it is, then the White man is the better one to put his life on the line.
Yes a White man or person can talk with authority on diversity issues. There are diverse issues among the Whites as well. What is the problem?
11:09 am
The article brought up a good point. The group of police and fire chiefs had more diversity within than it would appear on the surface being 97% white male. In our soundbite culture, every group is reduced to a monolithic “they.” Be careful when you or any group is reduced to an all-encompassing “they,” “them,” or “those people,” in your presence (or in your mind).
7:07 pm
The question itself indicates how often people conflate “race” – which is essentially, as it is presently used, a concept from the 17th century – diversity. And it is ironic that Americans (the “rugged individualists”) seem unable to recognize the many facets and factors that make up diversity.
Scott Brown’s recent dismissal of Elizabeth Warrens heritage – “Professor Warren claimed she was a Native American … and as you can see, she’s not.” – is unfortunately typical of the thinking (or lack of thinking) of too many people.
2:54 pm
Well said. How does someone who has never been discriminated against because of their skin color (nothing more and nothing less) explain that to anyone. How do you understand the feeling of this when it never has and probably never will happen to you. Whites can be disliked for various reasons, but Black people are disliked often on sight. At first glance, a Black person is often immediaely determined to be less than, not matter what the situation. q